Home · Kitchen · Water

The best water filter jugs, compared

Six filter jugs costed by what a cartridge really delivers before its date runs out, and checked for genuine certification, honest claims, waste and owner reviews.

By Mrs HouseUpdated October 20266 products compared
Phox V2 2.2L Glass Water FilterOur pick
3.7
Phox V2 2.2L Glass Water Filter
£39.99, 4.6p a litre to run
✓Refill sachets instead of plastic pods
✓4.6p a litre, eight refills a year
✓Made in Scotland, every part sold separately
The 10 second answer

Which one should you buy?

Side by side

Show me jugs that are…

Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.

Ranked by scorePhox#1 · 3.7Brita#2 · 3.5Waterdrop#3 · 3.4Amazon Basics#4 · 3.2Aarke#5 · 3.0ZeroWater#6 · 2.2
Keep the cartridge, no plastic pods✓✕✕✕✓✕
Certification listed in a public register✕✕tested, not certified✓taste and chlorine only✕✕✓
No unsupported PFAS or microplastics claim✓✕~sister listings overclaim✓✓✓
Under 5p a litre to run✓✕✓✓✕✕
Jug costs under £20✕✓✕✓✕✓
✓ yes✕ no~ partly? not stated
The reviews, ranked

Good, not so good, and the score

Phox V2 2.2L Glass Water Filter1
Best overall

Phox V2 2.2L Glass Water Filter

£39.99, 4.6p a litre to run
3.7

Keep the cartridge and refill it from a rice paper sachet: low waste, low running cost.

Good
✓Refill sachets instead of plastic pods
✓4.6p a litre, eight refills a year
✓Made in Scotland, every part sold separately
Not so good
✕No certificate or test report published
✕Slow flow and clogging often reported
✕£39.99 up front, four times cheapest
See it at Phox
Brita Marella 2.4L with MAXTRA PRO Pure Performance2
Most owners

Brita Marella 2.4L with MAXTRA PRO Pure Performance

£14.99, 5.6p to 7.5p a litre to run
3.5

The default with a real recycling scheme, but its jug cartridges are tested, not certified.

Good
✓Cartridge recycling scheme running since 1992
✓Names all four filter stages
✓Huge owner base, 4.7 from 24,218
Not so good
✕Jug cartridges not in the NSF register
✕Microplastics claim misses most small particles
✕13 cartridges a year, most waste here
See it at Robert Dyas
Waterdrop Chubby PT-04W 3.5L3
Cheapest branded run

Waterdrop Chubby PT-04W 3.5L

£25.99, 4p a litre to run
3.4

Genuinely certified and cheap to run, but only for chlorine and taste, not health claims.

Good
✓Certification checkable in the NSF register
✓4p a litre, four cartridges a year
✓Largest jug here at 3.5 litres
Not so good
✕Certified for taste and chlorine only
✕Three month limit wastes two thirds capacity
✕Weak UK after sales, no take back
See it at Waterdrop
Amazon Basics 2.3L Water Filter Jug4
Best on a budget

Amazon Basics 2.3L Water Filter Jug

£10.12, 3p a litre to run
3.2

The cheapest to run for less limescale and better taste, with no health claims made.

Good
✓3p a litre, about £33 a year
✓Cartridges also fit Brita jugs
✓Makes no lead, PFAS or microplastics claim
Not so good
✕TUV certified, but no standard named
✕Tips when full, cartridge stiff to remove
✕No take back, twelve pods to landfill
Check price at Amazon
Aarke Purifier, 2.36L5
Best hygiene design

Aarke Purifier, 2.36L

£99.99, 6.7p a litre to run
3.0

A refillable steel cartridge and fully dishwasher safe jug, but expensive to buy and run.

Good
✓Refillable stainless steel cartridge
✓Every part dishwasher safe at 60 degrees
✓Most specific published filtering figures
Not so good
✕£99.99, five to ten times rivals
✕No named lab behind its figures
✕26 per cent one star company reviews
See it at Lakeland
Culligan ZeroWater 1.7L, 5 Stage6
Avoid

Culligan ZeroWater 1.7L, 5 Stage

£19.99, 21p to 27.7p a litre to run
2.2

The only jug certified for lead removal, but £230 or more a year in cartridges.

Good
✓Only jug certified for health effects
✓Published lead and PFAS reduction figures
✓Meter shows when filter is spent
Not so good
✕£230 to £304 a year in cartridges
✕Fishy, metallic taste as filters wear out
✕New jug rates 1.5 out of 5
See it at Lakeland
What we found

What the labels don’t tell you

2 of 6

have certification you can find in a public register.

£230 to £304

a year in ZeroWater cartridges for two people drinking three litres a day.

93% to under 10%

is how far limescale removal falls over one cartridge's life, French testing found.

99.97%

of tap water samples in England and Wales meet the standards, the regulator reports.

Before you buy

The 30 second check

1Cost it by the four week date, not the litres on the box, since the date usually runs out first.
2Certified is not the same as tested, so check the model is listed in a public register.
3Check which standard it covers, as NSF/ANSI 42 is taste and chlorine only, not health.
4Change cartridges on time, because limescale removal falls from 93 per cent to under 10.
5Keep the jug in the fridge, empty rather than top up, and wash it, to stop bacteria growing.
How we scored these
Works 35%
Made of 25%
Value 15%
Everyday 15%
Honest 10%

Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.

4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.

Final verdict

Phox V2 for low waste and low running cost, Amazon Basics at £10.12 for cheap limescale control. Skip Culligan ZeroWater unless you need certified lead removal: £230 or more a year in cartridges.

See our pick