The best washing up liquids, compared
Six washing up liquids read against their own ingredient lists and dose instructions, costed per sink, and checked for skin-sensitising preservatives, fragrance and checkable certification.
Our pickWhich one should you buy?
Show me washing up liquids that are…
Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.
| Ranked by score | Ecover#1 · 3.8 | smol#2 · 3.5 | Bio-D#3 · 3.4 | Tesco#4 · 3.1 | Method#5 · 2.9 | Fairy#6 · 2.6 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tells you how much to use | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Full ingredient list published | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ~ranges plus preservatives | ✓ | ✕ |
| No skin-sensitising preservatives (MIT, BIT) | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✓ | ✕ |
| Fragrance free | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Certification you can look up | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Under 2p a wash at the maker's dose | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ?no dose given | ?no dose given | ?no dose given |
Good, not so good, and the score
1Ecover Washing Up Liquid, Lemon and Aloe Vera, 950ml
The only mass market bottle stating a dose, making it the cheapest per sink, with full ingredients.
Ecover wins this on one sentence printed on the back of the bottle: one squeeze, three millilitres in five litres, is enough for a sink full of dirty dishes. It is the only mass market brand here that gives you a number, and once you have a number the whole category rearranges itself. At three millilitres, a 950ml bottle does about 317 sinkfuls, which is 1.34p a wash. Buy the five litre refill and it drops to 0.94p. A year of washing up, using the regulator’s figure of 426 sinkfuls, costs £5.72 from bottles or £4.02 from the refill.
It also publishes a full INCI list on its own site, which the detergents regulation actually requires and which three of the six here do not do. That list is worth reading, because it contains a genuine surprise. The main surfactant is sodium lauryl sulfate, plain SLS, the ingredient the internet most often tells people to avoid, and the brand that most people assume uses the harshest chemistry is running the milder ethoxylated version instead. What the list does not contain is any preservative at all. No isothiazolinones, no phenoxyethanol. The regulation requires preservatives to be listed regardless of concentration, so an absence in a compliant list means something.
The weaknesses are real. The five litre refill saves 30 per cent, which is genuinely good, but the 950ml bottle at £4.47 a litre still looks expensive on a shelf next to a 62p Tesco bottle, and plenty of people will never do the sum. The company Trustpilot page sits at 1.5 out of 5, heavily weighted to laundry complaints but including two specifically about washing up liquid causing split fingertips and sore skin. And the Leaping Bunny and B Corp claims come without a licence number or a directory entry we could find.
Buy it if you want the lowest actual cost per sink and an ingredient list you can read, and you are prepared to measure rather than squirt.
2smol Washing Up Liquid, 4 x 500ml refill
A checkable B Corp with full ingredients and a stated dose, though owners say foam collapses.
smol is the only brand in this comparison whose certification we could look up and read a number against. It is a certified B Corp with a B Impact Score of 99.3, certified in December 2023, headquartered in Kent, and the entry is in the public directory. Everyone else here either has nothing or claims a logo without a licence number.
It also publishes a full INCI list on a dedicated ingredients page, and it publishes a dose count rather than a millilitre figure: roughly 125 doses per 500ml carton, which works out at four millilitres and 1.7p a wash. That is the second cleanest cost per wash in the group and, like Ecover, it only exists because the maker gave you the number. There is one detail nobody else here offers: denatonium benzoate, a bittering agent, so a child who gets it in their mouth spits it out.
Two things stop it winning. The first is that the surfactant story does not match the marketing. smol leads on sodium laureth sulfate, the ethoxylated sulfate, which is the same family as the professional Fairy formula rather than the glucoside-heavy chemistry the plant-powered positioning implies. The second is the evidence base. Its own comparison page still prices Fairy at a December 2023 figure, which is nearly three years stale and flatters smol badly. And its on-site review widget shows 427 reviews with not a single one star among them, which is not what a real review pool looks like. The independent forum comments tell a different story, and the theme is foam collapsing and people using more than the stated four millilitres. Since the whole 1.7p figure rests on that dose, that matters.
Buy it if you want a certification you can actually check, a published dose, and you are happy on a subscription.
3Bio-D Concentrated Washing Up Liquid, Fragrance Free, 750ml
No fragrance, preservatives or colourant, the pick for hand eczema, but dear per wash.
If your hands are the problem, this is the shortlist of one. No fragrance, so no fragrance allergens. No preservatives declared. No colourant. Made in the East Riding of Yorkshire by a company with the highest verified B Impact Score in this comparison at 104.3, certified in January 2022 and up from 80.2 two years earlier, against a median score for an ordinary business of 50.9. It has held Leaping Bunny approval for eighteen years, and it sells refills in five litre and twenty litre containers plus a network of zero waste shops that will decant it by weight.
Then it does something unusual, and we are going to give it credit for it even though it costs the product two places. It publishes an honest dose, and the honest dose is big: ten to fifteen millilitres, two teaspoons, for an average bowl. At the midpoint that is 4.57p a wash and only about 60 sinkfuls from a 750ml bottle, which makes it the second most expensive product here per wash. A brand that tells you the truth about how much you need finishes below brands that tell you nothing. That is the perverse incentive at the centre of this whole category and it is worth naming.
Its real failing is transparency, which is awkward given the positioning. Bio-D publishes regulation bands only, above 30 per cent anionic surfactant and below 5 per cent amphoteric, and names no actual surfactant anywhere on its site. Annex VII requires an INCI list to be available on a website. We could not find one. We also note that the product page gives a pH of 11.5, which is strongly alkaline for something you put your hands in, and which looks enough like a template error carried over from a laundry product that we would check the bottle before relying on it.
Buy it if you have sensitive hands or hand eczema and you want the fewest possible things in the bottle, and you are buying the five litre refill so the cost per wash comes down.
4Tesco Original Washing Up Liquid, 500ml
Cheapest per litre and rated above Fairy, but preserved with a blend linked to skin allergy.
62p for 500ml, which is £1.24 a litre, less than half what Fairy costs per litre and a fifth of what Method costs. It scores 3.9 out of 5 from 89 reviews at Tesco, which is a better score than Fairy Original manages on the same website. If you are choosing on price and your hands are fine, this is the sensible answer and no amount of packaging design changes that.
It also does one thing better than Fairy does. Tesco names its preservatives on the product page. The problem is what they are. The listing declares methylchloroisothiazolinone and methylisothiazolinone, which together are the blend sold as Kathon CG, and that mixture is the one behind the isothiazolinone contact allergy epidemic of the last fifteen years. In the guide below there is a British Journal of Dermatology study that concluded rinse-off products preserved with 50 parts per million of MI or more are not safe for consumers, and a Swiss market survey that measured MI in detergents at up to 279 parts per million. Detergents sit entirely outside the limits that apply to cosmetics.
On everything else it is thin. No millilitre dose published, so you cannot cost a wash. No INCI list, only regulation bands. No certifications of any kind. No recycled content figure for the bottle. It is a cheap bottle of washing up liquid that does what a cheap bottle of washing up liquid does, and the one thing you need to know about it is on the label if you look.
Buy it if price per litre is the thing you care about, nobody in the house has hand eczema or a known isothiazolinone allergy, and you wear gloves.
5Method Washing Up Liquid, Coconut Water, 532ml
The clearest ingredient list on the shelf, but the dearest per litre with no dose.
Method does the disclosure properly. Its own shop publishes a full INCI list with a function label against every single ingredient, which is the clearest presentation of any brand here, and its FAQ says plainly that it provides the full INCI list. There are no isothiazolinones and no phenoxyethanol, and it is the only product in this comparison that admits in writing to containing a colourant, even though it will not tell you which one. That is a small piece of honesty that Fairy, which is famously green, does not offer.
The problem is the money. At £3.50 for 532ml at Ocado it is £6.58 a litre, more than six times the price per litre of the cheapest own brand and nearly two and a half times Ecover. Which? recorded it at an even higher price earlier in the year, so it moves about. And Method does not publish how much liquid a pump delivers, so like Fairy it cannot be costed per wash from anything the maker says. Using the regulator’s default that comes out at 4.61p a wash and about £19.62 a year, the most expensive in this comparison.
The reviews are also the weakest here, which was not what we expected: 3.2 out of 5 from 47 reviews at Ocado, the lowest score of any product in the test, and 3.9 from 33 at Tesco. And the pump bottle, which is the reason a lot of people buy it, is a single use plastic item with a pump that is not straightforwardly recyclable.
Buy it if you want the clearest ingredient list on the shelf and a pump bottle you are happy to look at, and the price per litre genuinely does not matter to you.
6Fairy Original Washing Up Liquid, 1450ml
Much loved, but no dose, no findable ingredient list and the worst preservatives for eczema.
Let us be fair to it first. A great many people think Fairy cleans better than anything else, and the review counts back that up: 5 out of 5 from 2,662 reviews at Waitrose on the 654ml bottle, and 4.9 from 10,144 at Tesco on Platinum Quickwash. Our score is not a judgement on whether it shifts grease. It is a judgement on what the brand will tell you, and on that it finishes last.
It publishes no dose. The pack says the formula is so concentrated you only need a drop, and that you get ultra long lasting suds from every drop, and that is the entirety of the guidance. Without a millilitre figure the concentration claim cannot be tested and the cost per wash cannot be calculated, which is a convenient place for a brand whose whole position is that you use less of it. The hard comparative claim, that Fairy lasts twice as long as the next best selling brand, has quietly disappeared from the packs. It was defended successfully at the Advertising Standards Authority in September 2013 against Persil washing up liquid, a product that is not sold in the UK today, and the ruling is no longer on the ASA website. Nothing in it ever concerned Aldi, Tesco or Ecover. At 2026 prices the cheapest Fairy pack is 2.19 times the price per litre of Tesco own brand, so even if the claim were still true and still applied, you would break even at best.
Two other things. Fairy is the only product here declaring both benzisothiazolinone and methylisothiazolinone, plus phenoxyethanol on top, which makes it the worst choice in this group for anyone with hand eczema. And we could not find a full ingredient list for it anywhere: fairy.co.uk redirects to a domain parking page, fairy.com returns a 404, and the P and G UK ingredients hub has no product level data. Annex VII requires that list to be on a website. We looked at five retailers and four company domains and found only regulation bands.
Buy it if you have used it for years, it works for you, and you are buying the largest bottle rather than the refill or the small sizes.
What the labels don’t tell you
a wash for Ecover at its stated 3ml dose, the cheapest real cost per sink here.
contain skin-sensitising preservatives (MIT, MCI, BIT): the cheapest and the most famous.
the recommended dose is roughly what people use, with no cleaner dishes for it.
less water, almost, in a full dishwasher than washing the same load by hand.
The 30 second check
How we scored these
Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.
4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.
Ecover for the lowest real cost per sink and a readable ingredient list, Tesco at 62p if your hands are fine, Bio-D for sensitive hands. Skip Fairy: no dose, no ingredient list, two sensitising preservatives.