Home · Bathroom · Cleaning

The best toilet cleaners, compared

Six toilet cleaners compared on whether their germ claims name a real standard, hazard labels and mixing risks, limescale performance, harsh disinfectants, ingredient disclosure and price.

By Mrs HouseUpdated October 20266 products compared
Asda Cool Aqua Toilet Liquid Gel Cleaner, 750mlOur pick
3.5
Asda Cool Aqua Toilet Liquid Gel Cleaner, 750ml
74p for 750ml
✓Names standard, contact time and organisms
✓74p, the cheapest here
✓Warning label, not Danger
The 10 second answer

Which one should you buy?

Side by side

Show me cleaners that are…

Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.

Ranked by scoreAsda#1 · 3.5Ecover#2 · 3.3Harpic#3 · 3.1Domestos#4 · 3.0Bio-D#5 · 2.8Duck#6 · 2.5
Germ claim names a standard and time✓✕no germ claim made✕✕~contradicts itself✕
Shifts established limescale✕✕✓✕✕✕
No Danger or corrosive label✓✓✕✕✓✓
No harsh disinfectant✕✓✕?✓✓
Ingredients published online~portal shows other variant✓✕✓✕email on request✓
Under £2 a bottle✓✕✓✓✕✕
✓ yes✕ no~ partly? not stated
The reviews, ranked

Good, not so good, and the score

Asda Cool Aqua Toilet Liquid Gel Cleaner, 750ml1
Best overall

Asda Cool Aqua Toilet Liquid Gel Cleaner, 750ml

74p for 750ml
3.5

The only germ claim here you can actually check, for 74p.

Good
✓Names standard, contact time and organisms
✓74p, the cheapest here
✓Warning label, not Danger
Not so good
✕Contains a harsh disinfectant
✕Does little to established limescale
✕Only sold at Asda
See it at Asda
Ecover Toilet Cleaner, Pine and Mint, 750ml2
Cleanest pick

Ecover Toilet Cleaner, Pine and Mint, 750ml

£2.50 for 750ml
3.3

Publishes everything and claims nothing it cannot back, but it is weak on scale.

Good
✓Full ingredients and safety sheet online
✓Makes no germ claim it cannot back
✓No harsh disinfectant, no hazard label
Not so good
✕2.9 from 35 Ocado reviews
✕Too weak for established limescale
✕Over three times the Asda price
See it at Ocado
Harpic Power Plus 10X Clean & Protect Original, 750ml3
Best for limescale

Harpic Power Plus 10X Clean & Protect Original, 750ml

£1.78 for 750ml
3.1

The one for hard water scale, but keep it well away from bleach.

Good
✓Shifts established limescale
✓Thick formula clings under the rim
✓Cheaper than both eco brands
Not so good
✕Germ claim names no standard
✕Directions admit 60 minutes to disinfect
✕Corrosive, and mixing warning is buried
See it at Asda
Domestos Original Thick Bleach, 750ml4
Best on stains

Domestos Original Thick Bleach, 750ml

£1.50 for 750ml
3.0

Good on stains for £1.50, but dangerous with any acid cleaner.

Good
✓Whitens and removes organic stains
✓Full ingredient list published online
✓Thick formula holds on the bowl
Not so good
✕Does almost nothing to limescale
✕Danger label, toxic gas with acids
✕No standard or contact time for germs
See it at Asda
Bio-D Toilet Cleaner, Fragrance Free, 750ml5
Fragrance free

Bio-D Toilet Cleaner, Fragrance Free, 750ml

£2.99 for 750ml
2.8

Right for sensitive households, but its germ claim contradicts itself.

Good
✓Fragrance free
✓No harsh disinfectant or hazard label
✓Refills in 5 and 20 litres
Not so good
✕Germ test claim contradicts its own FAQ
✕Ingredient sheet only sent by email
✕Most expensive liquid here
See it at Ethical Superstore
Duck Fresh Discs, Mint Mission, 36ml6
Avoid

Duck Fresh Discs, Mint Mission, 36ml

£3.47 for 36ml
2.5

A fragrance product in the cleaning aisle. It freshens, it does not clean.

Good
✓Best ingredient disclosure here
✓Keeps the bowl smelling fresh
✓Rim product, safe for cistern parts
Not so good
✕Does not clean, descale or disinfect
✕Highest price per millilitre here
✕Owners say the dispenser is a nightmare
See it at Tesco
What we found

What the labels don’t tell you

1 of 6

cleaners here names a standard, a contact time and the organisms, and it costs 74p

99.9%

is a fail against EN 1276, the germ standard brands imply, which requires 99.999 per cent

60 minutes

contact time Harpic's own directions give for disinfection. Nobody leaves cleaner in the bowl that long

Before you buy

The 30 second check

1Never mix acid cleaner with bleach. Together they make chlorine gas in a small, closed room.
2Look for minutes next to germ claims. A kill claim without a contact time means very little.
3Match the product to the problem. Acid shifts limescale and bleach whitens stains. Nothing does both well.
4Use the brush. In research, brushing cut bowl bacteria more than any product.
5Keep bleach blocks out of the cistern. They can damage the fill valve. Rim blocks are a different thing.
How we scored these
Works 35%
Made of 25%
Value 15%
Everyday 15%
Honest 10%

Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.

4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.

Final verdict

Buy Asda Cool Aqua for a germ claim you can check, Harpic for hard water scale, or Ecover for an honest label. Skip Duck Fresh Discs, which only add fragrance.

See our pick