Home · Laundry · Stain removal

The best stain removers, compared

Six stain removers from £1.39 to £6.50, checked against their labels, safety sheets and the legal duty to publish ingredients, plus hazard warnings, wash temperature and cost per wash.

By Mrs HouseUpdated October 20266 products compared
Astonish Oxy Active Non Bio Stain Remover Powder, 1.25kgOur pick
3.4
Astonish Oxy Active Non Bio Stain Remover Powder, 1.25kg
£3.49 for 1.25kg, about 6p a wash
✓About 6p a wash, very cheap
✓Honestly says it needs 40 degrees plus
✓Same chemistry as pricier brands
The 10 second answer

Which one should you buy?

Side by side

Show me stain removers that are…

Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.

Ranked by scoreAstonish#1 · 3.4Bio-D#2 · 3.3Ocado#3 · 3.1Dr. Beckmann#4 · 3.0Vanish#5 · 2.6Ace#6 · 2.3
No Danger label for eye damage✕?✕✕✕?
No optical brighteners (whitening dyes)?✓✕✓✓✕
No warning of harm to water life✓?✓✓✓✕
Honest about the wash temperature needed✓✓??✕?
Ingredients readable online without a login~mostly unreadable~ranges only~ranges only~partial✕login needed~ranges only
Under 30p per 100g or 100ml✓✕✓✕✕✓
✓ yes✕ no~ partly? not stated
The reviews, ranked

Good, not so good, and the score

Astonish Oxy Active Non Bio Stain Remover Powder, 1.25kg1
Best overall

Astonish Oxy Active Non Bio Stain Remover Powder, 1.25kg

£3.49 for 1.25kg, about 6p a wash
3.4

The cheapest oxygen bleach that works and honest about temperature, but its ingredient list is broken.

Good
✓About 6p a wash, very cheap
✓Honestly says it needs 40 degrees plus
✓Same chemistry as pricier brands
Not so good
✕Ingredient document mostly unreadable spreadsheet errors
✕Danger label: causes serious eye damage
✕Spray's safety sheet contradicts its pack
See it at Astonish
Bio-D Laundry Bleach, 400g2
Cleanest pick

Bio-D Laundry Bleach, 400g

£2.10 for 400g, about 8.1p a wash
3.3

Fragrance free with no whitening dyes, from a B Corp that names its key ingredient.

Good
✓Names its low temperature activator, TAED
✓Fragrance free with no whitening dyes
✓Certified B Corp with published score
Not so good
✕Ingredient ranges only, no full list
✕Hazard warnings not published online
✕Small tub, pricier per gram
See it at Bio-D
Ocado Stain Remover Powder for Whites, 1kg3
Best on a budget

Ocado Stain Remover Powder for Whites, 1kg

£2.95 for 1kg, about 8.9p a wash
3.1

Cheap own brand whites powder from a tier that beats branded ones in independent tests.

Good
✓£2.95 a kilo, about 8.9p a wash
✓Own brand tier beats brands in tests
✓Names its preservatives on the pack
Not so good
✕Whitening dyes make things look whiter only
✕Danger label: causes serious eye damage
✕Sold only at Ocado
See it at Ocado
Dr. Beckmann Stain Devils Pre-Wash, 250ml4
Best for one stain

Dr. Beckmann Stain Devils Pre-Wash, 250ml

£2.75 for 250ml
3.0

A targeted pre wash that suits one known stain, at four times the cheapest per unit.

Good
✓Targeted formula beats general bleach
✓No whitening dyes, removes not disguises
✓Clear dosing instruction
Not so good
✕Four times the cheapest powder per unit
✕Only partial ingredient disclosure
✕Danger label: causes serious eye damage
See it at Dr. Beckmann
Vanish Oxi Action Powder, Colours, 1kg5
Avoid

Vanish Oxi Action Powder, Colours, 1kg

£6.50 for 1kg
2.6

Popular and well rated, but twice the price, the heaviest hazard label and ingredients behind a login.

Good
✓4.8 out of 5 from 191 Tesco reviews
✓In every supermarket, many formats
✓Colours version leaves out whitening dyes
Not so good
✕Ingredient list needs a login to see
✕Twice the price for the same chemistry
✕Heaviest hazard label: four warnings
See it at Tesco
Ace Ultra for Whites, 1 litre6
Avoid

Ace Ultra for Whites, 1 litre

£1.99 for 1 litre at Savers
2.3

The cheapest here, but the only one labelled very toxic to aquatic life.

Good
✓19.9p per 100ml, cheapest here
✓Brightens white cotton in a soak
✓Easy to find in discount chemists
Not so good
✕Labelled very toxic to aquatic life
✕Whitening dyes rather than extra cleaning
✕Whites only, no ingredient list published
See it at Ace
What we found

What the labels don’t tell you

1 of 6

meets the legal duty to publish a full ingredient list with open access.

5 of 6

carry the Danger warning: causes serious eye damage.

2 of 23

stain removers rated good by Stiftung Warentest, and a good washing powder beat them all.

6p

a wash for Astonish, less than half Vanish's price per gram.

Before you buy

The 30 second check

1Try more of your usual detergent first, as independent tests found good powder beat dedicated stain removers.
2Match the product to the stain, enzymes for blood and egg, oxygen bleach for tea and wine.
3Never hot wash a protein stain, because heat sets blood, egg and sweat into the fabric for good.
4Buy on price per 100 grams, since cheap and dear tubs share the same oxygen bleach.
5Test colour safe claims on a seam, because patchy coloured clothes were the commonest one star complaint.
How we scored these
Works 35%
Made of 25%
Value 15%
Everyday 15%
Honest 10%

Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.

4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.

Final verdict

Astonish Oxy Active at about 6p a wash on price, Bio-D Laundry Bleach for no fragrance or brighteners. Skip Ace Ultra, the only one labelled very toxic to aquatic life.

See our pick