The best stain removers, compared
Six stain removers from £1.39 to £6.50, checked against their labels, safety sheets and the legal duty to publish ingredients, plus hazard warnings, wash temperature and cost per wash.
Our pickWhich one should you buy?
Show me stain removers that are…
Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.
| Ranked by score | Astonish#1 · 3.4 | Bio-D#2 · 3.3 | Ocado#3 · 3.1 | Dr. Beckmann#4 · 3.0 | Vanish#5 · 2.6 | Ace#6 · 2.3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No Danger label for eye damage | ✕ | ? | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ? |
| No optical brighteners (whitening dyes) | ? | ✓ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ |
| No warning of harm to water life | ✓ | ? | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ |
| Honest about the wash temperature needed | ✓ | ✓ | ? | ? | ✕ | ? |
| Ingredients readable online without a login | ~mostly unreadable | ~ranges only | ~ranges only | ~partial | ✕login needed | ~ranges only |
| Under 30p per 100g or 100ml | ✓ | ✕ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ |
Good, not so good, and the score
1Astonish Oxy Active Non Bio Stain Remover Powder, 1.25kg
The cheapest oxygen bleach that works and honest about temperature, but its ingredient list is broken.
£3.49 for 1.25kg at B&M, which works out at about 6.1p a wash and 27.9p per 100g. That is less than half the price per gram of Vanish and it is the same underlying chemistry: sodium percarbonate, which releases hydrogen peroxide in water and does the actual bleaching. On oxygen bleach there is no premium ingredient to buy. There is percarbonate, an activator, some surfactant and a fragrance, and the difference between a £3.49 tub and a £6.50 one is mostly the brand on the front.
It is also, of this group, the most honest about temperature. Astonish states 40 degrees or above for an in wash dose and 40 to 60 degrees for soaking. That is the truth about percarbonate, which bleaches poorly below 40 unless there is enough of the activator TAED in the mix. Vanish, by contrast, sells the same chemistry on the line that it works even in a cold wash at 30 while its own pack caps the soak at 40. Tesco manages to contradict itself between two pack sizes of the same product, with 500g saying even at 30 degrees and 1kg instructing a 40 to 50 degree soak.
Where it comes badly unstuck is the ingredient list, and this is worth describing exactly because it is not the usual story of a brand declining to publish. Astonish does publish a PDF. We downloaded it and read it. Rows four to twenty eight all read hash N slash A, which is a spreadsheet error exported into a document, leaving three legible ingredients out of twenty eight. So we cannot tell you whether it contains optical brighteners or isothiazolinones. There is also a live discrepancy between the safety data sheet for the spray version and its retail pack: the sheet lists H318 and H319 together with the signal word Warning, which is not a valid combination under CLP, while the pack says only H319.
Buy it if you want oxygen bleach at the lowest sensible price, you wash at 40 rather than 30, and you keep it away from children and out of eyes.
2Bio-D Laundry Bleach, 400g
Fragrance free with no whitening dyes, from a B Corp that names its key ingredient.
Bio-D is the only brand in this comparison that names TAED in its own ingredient list, and that single detail tells you the maker understands its own product. TAED is tetraacetylethylenediamine, the activator that lets sodium percarbonate bleach at lower temperatures. Without it, percarbonate needs real heat. With it, a 30 or 40 degree wash becomes arguable. Every brand here relies on it. One names it.
It is also fragrance free, declares no optical brighteners, and comes from a certified B Corp in the East Riding of Yorkshire with a published impact score, which is more independent verification than anything else on this page carries. At about 8.1p a wash it is not the cheapest, but it is close to the middle of the group and well under the market leader.
The gaps are real and we are not going to skate over them. Bio-D publishes label bands rather than a full INCI list, which is the same criticism we made of its washing up liquid, and it is a strange gap for a brand that sells itself on transparency. Its hazard statements are not published online at all, so you find out what warnings the tub carries when it arrives. And no certificate numbers are given for the Leaping Bunny or Vegan Society marks it displays.
Buy it if you want the shortest ingredient list, no fragrance and a maker with a certification you can look up.
3Ocado Stain Remover Powder for Whites, 1kg
Cheap own brand whites powder from a tier that beats branded ones in independent tests.
£2.95 for a kilo, about 8.9p a wash, and in independent testing this tier consistently holds its own. The Independent’s group test put Tesco Oxypower at £3.15 and Waitrose Essential at £3.25 ahead of the branded field, which is the same finding every group test in this category reaches: the supermarket powder is the same percarbonate and it works.
It carries optical brighteners, which is the honest reason a whites powder makes things look whiter than a colours one. Optical brighteners are fluorescent dyes that absorb ultraviolet and re emit it as blue, which cancels the yellow cast of ageing cotton. They do not remove anything. That is not a scandal, it is how every whitening product on the shelf works, but it is worth understanding that a good part of the whiter than white effect is optics rather than cleaning.
The label is bands only, no INCI list, and the hazard warning is the one everybody in this category shares: Danger, H318, causes serious eye damage, with the precautionary statement telling you to call a poison centre immediately. On a £2.95 tub of laundry powder that is a genuinely startling thing to read, and it is on almost all of them.
Buy it if you want the cheapest thing that works on white cotton and you are not troubled by optical brighteners.
4Dr. Beckmann Stain Devils Pre-Wash, 250ml
A targeted pre wash that suits one known stain, at four times the cheapest per unit.
Dr. Beckmann does something the rest of this group does not: it sells different products for different stains, because different stains need different chemistry. Protein stains such as blood, egg and milk need enzymes and cool water. Tannin stains such as tea, wine and grass need oxygen bleach. Grease needs a surfactant and a solvent. One tub of percarbonate is not good at all three, whatever the front of the pack says, and a targeted product genuinely can outperform a general one on the stain it was made for.
It is also the only product here that declares no optical brighteners, which for a pre wash makes sense: it is meant to remove the stain, not disguise the fabric.
Against that, it is much the most expensive per unit at £1.10 per 100ml, which is four times the Astonish powder. Disclosure is partial rather than full, and the version of the range that does name its isothiazolinones is the Power Brush rather than this one, which was out of stock on the maker’s own site when we looked. It carries the same Danger and H318 as the rest.
Buy it if you have one recurring stain problem you can name, and you would rather solve that than buy a general purpose tub.
5Vanish Oxi Action Powder, Colours, 1kg
Popular and well rated, but twice the price, the heaviest hazard label and ingredients behind a login.
Vanish is the brand everyone reaches for and it scores 4.8 out of 5 from 191 reviews at Tesco, so plenty of people are happy. We are not going to tell you it does not work. What we can tell you is what happened when we tried to find out what is in it.
The pack points you to Reckitt’s ingredient portal. Annex VII of the detergents regulation is explicit that access to the manufacturer’s ingredient website must not be subject to any restriction or condition. We tested it. The products endpoint redirects to a login page. The ingredients page returns Page Not Found with a login link. The root is an empty application shell. There is no route to a Vanish ingredient data sheet without an account. That is the market leader in this category, and on our reading it does not meet the duty.
Two other things. At £6.50 a kilo it is 65p per 100g, which is 2.3 times the Astonish powder and 2.2 times the Ocado own brand for the same underlying percarbonate chemistry. And it carries the heaviest hazard label of the six: Danger, with H318 causes serious eye damage, H315 causes skin irritation, H272 may intensify fire as an oxidiser, and H302 harmful if swallowed. Worth knowing before it goes in a cupboard a child can reach. The same formula sold in Australia rates 1.6 out of 5 from 176 reviews with 88 per cent negative, against 4.8 here, which is a gap large enough to be worth mentioning even though we cannot explain it.
Buy it if it has always worked for you and you would rather not change, having read the hazard statements above.
6Ace Ultra for Whites, 1 litre
The cheapest here, but the only one labelled very toxic to aquatic life.
£1.99 a litre at Savers, which is 19.9p per 100ml and the cheapest thing on this page. If all you want is to brighten white cotton in a soak, it will do that.
The reason it finishes last is a single line on the label that none of the others carry: H410, very toxic to aquatic life with long lasting effects. That is the most serious environmental hazard classification in ordinary consumer use, and it is on a £1.99 bottle that goes down the drain by design. Everything in this comparison ends up in the wastewater system, but this is the only one whose own label says that is a problem.
It also carries optical brighteners, publishes label bands only rather than an ingredient list, and offers no certifications of any kind. On a whites product the brighteners are at least doing the job people buy it for, but combined with the aquatic classification it makes for a product that is cheap in one specific and narrow sense.
Buy it if you want the cheapest possible whites soak and the aquatic toxicity classification does not trouble you.
What the labels don’t tell you
meets the legal duty to publish a full ingredient list with open access.
carry the Danger warning: causes serious eye damage.
stain removers rated good by Stiftung Warentest, and a good washing powder beat them all.
a wash for Astonish, less than half Vanish's price per gram.
The 30 second check
How we scored these
Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.
4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.
Astonish Oxy Active at about 6p a wash on price, Bio-D Laundry Bleach for no fragrance or brighteners. Skip Ace Ultra, the only one labelled very toxic to aquatic life.