The best non-bio laundry detergents, compared
Eight non-bio detergents compared on fragrance, optical brighteners, preservatives, price per wash and how much each brand tells you about what is in the bottle.
Our pickWhich one should you buy?
Show me detergents that are…
Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.
| Ranked by score | Bio-D#1 · 3.9 | Ecover Zero#2 · 3.7 | smol#3 · 3.5 | Surcare#4 · 3.3 | Fairy#6 · 3.0 | Persil#7 · 2.9 | Ecoleaf#8 · 2.7 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No perfume | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ |
| No optical brighteners | ✓ | ✓ | ✕Not flagged on page | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ |
| No skin-sensitising preservative (MIT, BIT) | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓Uses phenoxyethanol | ? | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Full ingredient list published | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ~Two lists conflict | ✕ |
| Under 20p a wash | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ?No wash count |
Good, not so good, and the score
1Bio-D Concentrated Non-Bio Laundry Liquid, Fragrance Free, 1L
Seven ingredients with no perfume, brightener or preservative, and Allergy UK lists it by name.
£6.50 for a litre, 25 washes, 26p a wash. The ingredient list is seven things long: vegetable oil soap, water, a glucose derived detergent, ethanol, a natural anionic detergent, trisodium citrate and citric acid. No perfume, no optical brighteners, no preservative declared, no enzymes. On a shelf where the average list runs to phosphonates, brighteners, benzisothiazolinone and perfume, that is a different kind of product.
It is Allergy UK certified, a certified B Corporation, Vegan Society approved and a King’s Award holder, and it is made in Hull. We could not find a certificate number for the Allergy UK claim, which is the one criticism that applies to almost every brand on this page, and Allergy UK’s own site does list Bio-D by name, which is more than most can say.
The honest limits are price and expectation. At 26p a wash it is close to four times the Aldi. And a detergent with no brighteners will not make your whites look brighter, because brighteners are the thing that does that. If you switch from Fairy your whites will look slightly duller and be exactly as clean, and it is worth knowing that in advance rather than concluding the stuff does not work.
Buy it if somebody in the house has eczema or reactive skin and you want the shortest ingredient list on the shelf. Skip it if you are washing for a large family on a budget, because this is one of the dearest per wash here.
2Ecover Zero Non-Bio Laundry Liquid, 1.43L
The only one publishing a full ingredient list, but the dearest per wash here.
£12.35 for 1.43 litres, 40 washes, 31p a wash, and it is the only product on this page that publishes a full INCI list rather than the banded summary the regulations require. Water, sodium lauryl sulfate, laureth-7, alcohol, potassium oleate, sodium citrate, tetrasodium glutamate diacetate, a bio polyester, propylene glycol, citric acid and isopropyl alcohol. It even publishes its UFI code. That is the standard everything on this shelf should be held to.
No fragrance, no enzymes, no optical brighteners and no preservative named. Ecover markets it as approved by the British Allergy Foundation, which is Allergy UK under its older name, and as with everyone else here there is no licence number to check.
It is the most expensive per wash on this page. And a caution that is about the shop rather than the bottle: Ecover Direct sits at 4.3 on Trustpilot across more than a thousand reviews, and the negative ones are overwhelmingly about delivery waits, damaged parcels and unanswered emails rather than the detergent. Buy it in a supermarket and that whole problem disappears.
Buy it if you want the shortest possible distance between what is in the bottle and what you can read. Skip it if you buy on price per wash.
3smol Non-Bio Fragrance and Colour Free Capsules
Convenient capsules with the Allergy UK seal, but an optical brightener it does not flag.
£6 for 24 capsules, 25p a wash, delivered through the letterbox, and it holds the Allergy UK Seal of Approval specifically on this fragrance and colour free version rather than on the range as a whole. Allergy UK lists it by name on its own site. That is a genuinely good credential and smol publishes its full ingredient list for every variant, which puts it ahead of most of the shelf.
And publishing that list is how we found the catch. The fragrance and colour free capsule still contains disodium distyrylbiphenyl disulfonate. That is an optical brightener, a stilbene type fluorescent whitening agent, and it is in the version sold to people avoiding additives. smol does not flag it as a brightener anywhere on the page. Nothing here is hidden, because the name is printed, but you would have to know what that word means, and the entire point of a fragrance and colour free line is that you should not have to.
The wider picture on capsules is that dosing is fixed. One for a normal load, two for a big or hard water load, which is where the price per wash quietly doubles. Owners like the convenience and report that the scent fades on larger loads in the scented versions, which is not a concern for this one.
Buy it if you want the convenience and the Allergy UK seal and you are not fussed about a brightener. Skip it if you are avoiding additives on principle, because there is one in here you would not expect.
4Surcare Sensitive Non Bio Laundry Liquid, 750ml
The cheapest way here to avoid both perfume and optical brighteners.
£5 for 750ml, 30 washes, 17p a wash, and it is the cheapest way on this page to get a detergent with no fragrance and no optical brighteners in it. Surcare has been doing exactly one thing for decades and the formulation shows it: surfactants, soap, phosphonates, a cationic surfactant and phenoxyethanol as the preservative. No perfume, no brighteners, no enzymes.
Two things stop it scoring higher. It is a banded declaration rather than a real ingredient list, so you are told there are 15 to 30 per cent anionic surfactants without being told which. And the hazard statement on the pack is causes serious eye damage, which is the strongest warning on this page and sits oddly on a product bought for sensitive skin. That is about splashing concentrate in your eye rather than about washed clothes, and it is still worth knowing if there are children in the house.
It is dermatologically approved with no body named and no number given, and the Tesco listing had no reviews at all when we looked, so there is no owner evidence to weigh either way.
Buy it if you want fragrance free and brightener free without paying the clean brand premium. Skip it if you want to read a real ingredient list.
Almat Super Concentrated Non Bio (Aldi), 1.47L
Under a third of the price of anything else, with the usual perfume and brighteners.
About £2.79 for 1.47 litres and 42 washes, which is roughly 7p a wash and less than a third of anything else on this page. Aldi’s own laundry range has taken Which? awards more than once, and this non bio liquid scored 61 per cent and a Great Value award rather than a Best Buy, which is a fair description of it.
The ingredients are the standard supermarket non bio set: anionic and non ionic surfactants, soap, phosphonates, polycarboxylates, optical brighteners and perfumes. So it has the two things the top of this page does not, and it has them at a fifth of the price. If nobody in your house reacts to anything, that is a perfectly rational trade and we are not going to sneer at it.
What we will mark it down for is that we could not get any of this from Aldi. Their site blocked us throughout, there is no published ingredient page we could reach, the price and wash count come from a price comparison site and a first hand reviewer, and there is no aggregated review pool for the product anywhere. For the cheapest thing on the shelf that is a shame rather than a scandal, but a shopper cannot check any of it.
Buy it if price per wash is the number that matters and nobody in the house has reactive skin. Skip it if you need to be able to check what is in it before you buy it.
6Fairy Non Biological Washing Liquid, 3.13L
Cleans well and good value, but sold for sensitive skin while containing perfume and sensitisers.
£16 for 3.13 litres and 101 washes, which is about 16p a wash, and it is the bottle most of the country reaches for when a baby arrives. It cleans well, it is everywhere, and on value it is genuinely competitive at that size.
The problem is what it is sold on. Fairy carries a Skin Health Alliance seal and the line about being the number one laundry brand for sensitive skin, and the declaration on the back reads: anionic and non ionic surfactants, phosphonates, soap, optical brighteners, preservatives, benzisothiazolinone, perfumes. So the product bought to be gentle contains a fragrance, a fluorescent whitening agent and an isothiazolinone preservative, and the thing it is defined by removing, enzymes, is the ingredient the dermatology literature says was not causing the trouble in the first place.
None of that means it will hurt you. Benzisothiazolinone is used at a fraction of a per cent and most people wear these clothes without incident. It does mean the sensitive skin promise is doing work the formulation does not support, and if that promise is why you buy it, four products higher up this page keep it better and two of them cost less per wash.
Buy it if you want a big brand that cleans and you have no skin concerns at all. Skip it if you are buying it because somebody in the house reacts, because this is not the formulation for that.
7Persil Non Bio Laundry Liquid, 1.84L
It cleans, but publishes two conflicting ingredient lists and contains known skin sensitisers.
£11 for 1.84 litres and 68 washes, about 16p a wash, 4.8 from 111 reviews, and it cleans. It is recognised by the British Skin Foundation, which is a real organisation, and as ever there is no reference number to check.
The declaration on the shelf edge reads: 15 to 30 per cent anionic surfactants, 5 to 15 per cent non ionic, and under 5 per cent perfume, phosphonates, soap, optical brighteners and benzisothiazolinone. The hazard statements printed alongside it are causes serious eye irritation, causes skin irritation, and may produce an allergic reaction. Those are on the concentrate rather than on a washed shirt, and they are still an unusual set of words to find on a bottle bought to be kind to skin.
What tipped it below Fairy is that Unilever publishes a different ingredient list for the same product on its own transparency site, naming methylisothiazolinone and octylisothiazolinone as the preservatives instead of benzisothiazolinone, and then disclaims that the list may not match the pack. Two published lists for one bottle, with a note saying do not rely on this one, is worse than publishing nothing at all.
Buy it if you already use it, it works for you and nobody reacts. Skip it if you want to know which preservative is actually in the bottle, because there are two answers.
8Ecoleaf Non-Bio Laundry Liquid, Fragrance Free, 1.5L
Good ethics and fragrance free, but no wash count and a sensitising preservative.
£7.59 for 1.5 litres, and this one is last for reasons that have nothing to do with ethos. Ecoleaf is a Suma product, Leaping Bunny and Vegan Society approved, an Ethical Consumer Best Buy, and on values it belongs near the top of this page.
It does not publish a wash count. That is the single most basic number on a bottle of detergent and without it you cannot work out what a wash costs, which means it cannot be compared with anything else here. We are not going to estimate one from a different sized bottle of a different variant and present that as a price.
The formulation is also odd for the market it is aimed at. It is fragrance free and brightener free, which is right, and then the preservative is benzisothiazolinone, the same isothiazolinone we have marked Fairy and Persil down for, in a product whose whole proposition is sensitive skin. And there were no reviews at all on either retailer listing we checked, so there is no owner evidence to set against any of it.
Buy it if you buy on values and you already know how far a bottle goes for you. Skip it if you need to compare what a wash costs, because Ecoleaf will not tell you.
What the labels don’t tell you
are fragrance free, and three of those are in the top four
a wash, a fourfold spread you cannot see from the shelf
British Journal of Dermatology paper calling the enzyme fear largely a British myth
The 30 second check
How we scored these
Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.
4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.
Buy Bio-D Fragrance Free at 26p a wash if someone reacts, or Aldi Almat at about 7p if nobody does. Skip Persil and Fairy, which add perfume, brighteners and sensitising preservatives.