Home · Laundry · Detergents and softeners

The best non-bio laundry detergents, compared

Eight non-bio detergents compared on fragrance, optical brighteners, preservatives, price per wash and how much each brand tells you about what is in the bottle.

By Mrs HouseUpdated October 20268 products compared
Bio-D Concentrated Non-Bio Laundry Liquid, Fragrance Free, 1LOur pick
3.9
Bio-D Concentrated Non-Bio Laundry Liquid, Fragrance Free, 1L
£6.50 for 1 litre, 26p a wash
✓Seven ingredients, no perfume or brightener
✓Allergy UK lists Bio-D by name
✓4.5 from 50 reviews
The 10 second answer

Which one should you buy?

Side by side

Show me detergents that are…

Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.

Ranked by scoreBio-D#1 · 3.9Ecover Zero#2 · 3.7smol#3 · 3.5Surcare#4 · 3.3Almat#5 · 3.2Fairy#6 · 3.0Persil#7 · 2.9Ecoleaf#8 · 2.7
No perfume✓✓✓✓✕✕✕✓
No optical brighteners✓✓✕Not flagged on page✓✕✕✕✓
No skin-sensitising preservative (MIT, BIT)✓✓✓✓Uses phenoxyethanol?✕✕✕
Full ingredient list published✓✓✓✕✕✕~Two lists conflict✕
Under 20p a wash✕✕✕✓✓✓✓?No wash count
✓ yes✕ no~ partly? not stated
The reviews, ranked

Good, not so good, and the score

Bio-D Concentrated Non-Bio Laundry Liquid, Fragrance Free, 1L1
Best overall

Bio-D Concentrated Non-Bio Laundry Liquid, Fragrance Free, 1L

£6.50 for 1 litre, 26p a wash
3.9

Seven ingredients with no perfume, brightener or preservative, and Allergy UK lists it by name.

Good
✓Seven ingredients, no perfume or brightener
✓Allergy UK lists Bio-D by name
✓4.5 from 50 reviews
Not so good
✕26p a wash, nearly 4x Aldi
✕Whites look duller without brighteners
✕No Allergy UK certificate number
See it at Bio-D
Ecover Zero Non-Bio Laundry Liquid, 1.43L2
Full ingredient list

Ecover Zero Non-Bio Laundry Liquid, 1.43L

£12.35 for 1.43 litres, 31p a wash
3.7

The only one publishing a full ingredient list, but the dearest per wash here.

Good
✓Publishes a full ingredient list
✓No fragrance, brighteners or named preservative
✓Bottle is 100 per cent recycled plastic
Not so good
✕31p a wash, the highest here
✕Allergy UK approval with no licence number
✕Wash counts differ between sources
See it at Ecover
smol Non-Bio Fragrance and Colour Free Capsules3
Allergy UK seal

smol Non-Bio Fragrance and Colour Free Capsules

£6 for 24 capsules, 25p a wash
3.5

Convenient capsules with the Allergy UK seal, but an optical brightener it does not flag.

Good
✓Allergy UK seal on this exact product
✓Full ingredient list for every variant
✓No fragrance, colourant or enzymes
Not so good
✕Contains an unflagged optical brightener
✕50p a wash on large loads
✕Owners report friction cancelling the subscription
See it at smol
Surcare Sensitive Non Bio Laundry Liquid, 750ml4
Cheapest fragrance free

Surcare Sensitive Non Bio Laundry Liquid, 750ml

£5 for 750ml, 17p a wash
3.3

The cheapest way here to avoid both perfume and optical brighteners.

Good
✓No fragrance or brighteners at 17p
✓Uses a gentler preservative (phenoxyethanol)
✓Widely stocked in supermarkets
Not so good
✕Vague ingredient bands, not a real list
✕Warns of serious eye damage
✕No reviews on the retailer listing
See it at Tesco
Almat Super Concentrated Non Bio (Aldi), 1.47L5
Best on a budget

Almat Super Concentrated Non Bio (Aldi), 1.47L

About £2.79 for 1.47 litres, about 7p a wash
3.2

Under a third of the price of anything else, with the usual perfume and brighteners.

Good
✓About 7p a wash, cheapest by far
✓Which? Great Value award
✓Long-term owners report no reactions
Not so good
✕Contains optical brighteners and perfume
✕No ingredient page from Aldi
✕Preservative not published
See it at Aldi
Fairy Non Biological Washing Liquid, 3.13L6
Market leader

Fairy Non Biological Washing Liquid, 3.13L

£16 for 3.13 litres, about 16p a wash
3.0

Cleans well and good value, but sold for sensitive skin while containing perfume and sensitisers.

Good
✓About 16p a wash on large bottle
✓Cleans well, stocked everywhere
✓Declaration published on retailer listing
Not so good
✕Perfume, brighteners and skin-sensitising preservative (BIT)
✕Sold for sensitive skin despite these
✕Barely any retailer reviews
See it at Tesco
Persil Non Bio Laundry Liquid, 1.84L7
Avoid

Persil Non Bio Laundry Liquid, 1.84L

£11 for 1.84 litres, about 16p a wash
2.9

It cleans, but publishes two conflicting ingredient lists and contains known skin sensitisers.

Good
✓4.8 from 111 reviews
✓About 16p a wash
✓Recognised by the British Skin Foundation
Not so good
✕Perfume, brighteners and skin-sensitising preservative
✕Two different ingredient lists published
✕Pack warns of skin irritation
See it at Tesco
Ecoleaf Non-Bio Laundry Liquid, Fragrance Free, 1.5L8
Last place

Ecoleaf Non-Bio Laundry Liquid, Fragrance Free, 1.5L

£7.59 for 1.5 litres
2.7

Good ethics and fragrance free, but no wash count and a sensitising preservative.

Good
✓Fragrance free, no optical brighteners
✓Leaping Bunny and Vegan Society approved
✓Refillable through Suma and independent shops
Not so good
✕No wash count, so no per-wash price
✕Skin-sensitising preservative (BIT) for sensitive skin
✕No reviews on retailer listings
See it at Suma
What we found

What the labels don’t tell you

4 of 8

are fragrance free, and three of those are in the top four

7p to 31p

a wash, a fourfold spread you cannot see from the shelf

2008

British Journal of Dermatology paper calling the enzyme fear largely a British myth

Before you buy

The 30 second check

1Look for fragrance free, not non bio, fragrance is what dermatology links to skin reactions.
2Read the preservative, MIT and BIT are recognised skin sensitisers.
3Know what brighteners do, they make whites look whiter but clean nothing.
4Work out the price per wash, it runs from about 7p to 31p here.
5Use less than it says, doses assume a heavily soiled load in hard water.
How we scored these
Works 35%
Made of 25%
Value 15%
Everyday 15%
Honest 10%

Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.

4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.

Final verdict

Buy Bio-D Fragrance Free at 26p a wash if someone reacts, or Aldi Almat at about 7p if nobody does. Skip Persil and Fairy, which add perfume, brighteners and sensitising preservatives.

See our pick