Home · Bedroom · Mattresses and toppers

The best mattress toppers, compared

Six mattress toppers compared on comfort, value and what they are made of: foam or not, flame retardant chemicals, fumes from new foam, published certificates and washability.

By Mrs HouseUpdated October 20266 products compared
Woolroom Deluxe Wool Mattress TopperOur pick
4.7
Woolroom Deluxe Wool Mattress Topper
£289.99 for a double
✓No foam, so nothing to air out
✓OEKO-TEX Class 1, the infant tier
✓Testers who sleep hot rated it
The 10 second answer

Which one should you buy?

Side by side

Show me toppers that are…

Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.

Ranked by scoreWoolroom#1 · 4.7Devon Duvets#2 · 4.5Simba#3 · 4.3Soak and Sleep#4 · 4.2Panda#5 · 4.0Silentnight#6 · 3.5
No foam✓✓✕✓✕✓
No flame retardant chemicals✓✓✕✓✕✓
Certificate published (OEKO-TEX, CertiPUR etc.)✓~cotton mill only✓CertiPUR foam✕✓✕
Machine washable✕✕~cover only✕~cover only✓
Fixes a mattress that is too firm✕✕✓✕✓✕
Under £200 for a double✕✕✕✓✓✓
✓ yes✕ no~ partly? not stated
The reviews, ranked

Good, not so good, and the score

Woolroom Deluxe Wool Mattress Topper1
Best overall

Woolroom Deluxe Wool Mattress Topper

£289.99 for a double
4.7

The cleanest topper on the UK market, but dry clean only and pricey.

Good
✓No foam, so nothing to air out
✓OEKO-TEX Class 1, the infant tier
✓Testers who sleep hot rated it
Not so good
✕Dry clean only
✕Too thin to fix a bad mattress
✕You feel a partner move
See it at Woolroom
Devon Duvets 100% British Wool Mattress Topper2
Best value

Devon Duvets 100% British Wool Mattress Topper

Around £210 for a double
4.5

The same clean wool idea for less, without a certificate you can check.

Good
✓Thicker 1200gsm British wool
✓About £80 less than the Woolroom
✓Owners report no chemical smell
Not so good
✕Spot clean only
✕No certificate on the finished topper
✕Heavy, and some wanted more loft
See it at Devon Duvets
Simba Hybrid Topper3
For firm mattresses

Simba Hybrid Topper

£349 for a double
4.3

The honest fix for a too firm mattress, but it is foam.

Good
✓Genuinely fixes a too firm mattress
✓Microsprings damp partner movement
✓Machine washable cover, 200 night trial
Not so good
✕Foam that gives off fumes when new
✕Contains flame retardants, type not published
✕Some say it worsened back pain
See it at Simba
Soak and Sleep Goose Down Dual Chamber Topper4
Softest

Soak and Sleep Goose Down Dual Chamber Topper

Around £190 for a double
4.2

Hotel softness without foam, if you keep up with the care.

Good
✓Hotel softness with no foam
✓Cassette build stops the fill shifting
✓Superclean rated down
Not so good
✕Professional clean about every six months
✕No use with a feather allergy
✕Softness only, no support
See it at Soak and Sleep
Panda Bamboo Mattress Topper5
Best selling

Panda Bamboo Mattress Topper

£139.95 for a double
4.0

The mainstream foam topper at a fair price, but smell and heat complaints are common.

Good
✓Softens a too firm bed
✓Removable washable cover
✓4.8 from 7,077 Dunelm reviews
Not so good
✕Many still sleep hot despite gel
✕Foam smell lasted days for some
✕Some report it firming or trenching
See it at Panda London
Silentnight Airmax Mattress Topper6
Weakest here

Silentnight Airmax Mattress Topper

£38 for a double
3.5

Fine for a guest or child's bed, but a short lived buy.

Good
✓Machine washable whole
✓Air mesh sides help airflow
✓No foam or flame retardants
Not so good
✕Flattens within two to three years
✕Sheds the most plastic microfibres here
✕No certifications, two year warranty
See it at Silentnight
What we found

What the labels don’t tell you

4 of 6

toppers here contain no foam, no adhesive and no flame retardant chemicals

48 hours

minimum airing for a new foam topper before you sleep on it

10 years

and more is the service life owners report for wool, against two to three years for hollowfibre

Before you buy

The 30 second check

1Decide what problem you have. A topper can fix a firm mattress, not a worn out one.
2Read the fill, not the name. Some toppers sold as wool are polyester with a wool face fabric.
3Choose 4 to 5cm for most beds. Go 6 to 8cm only for a too firm mattress or pressure pain.
4Air any foam topper first. Unwrap it in a ventilated room and wait at least 48 hours.
5Cover it with a washable protector. Wool, down and foam toppers cannot go in the machine whole.
How we scored these
Works 35%
Made of 25%
Value 15%
Everyday 15%
Honest 10%

Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.

4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.

Final verdict

Buy the Woolroom Deluxe for the cleanest topper, or Devon Duvets for wool at less. Choose the Simba only if your mattress is too firm. Skip the Airmax if you want it to last.

See our pick