Home · Bedroom · Bedding hygiene

The best mattress protectors, compared

Six mattress protectors compared on what the waterproof layer is made of, whether certifications check out on the register, washing and fit, and what owners report months later.

By Mrs HouseUpdated October 20266 products compared
Panda Bamboo Mattress ProtectorOur pick
3.9
Panda Bamboo Mattress Protector
£33.30 for a double
✓Waterproof TPU film, not vinyl
✓Stretch skirt stays put on deep mattresses
✓4.61 from 540 reviews, 4.59 at Dunelm
The 10 second answer

Which one should you buy?

Side by side

Show me protectors that are…

Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.

Ranked by scorePanda#1 · 3.9Utopia#2 · 3.9Woolroom#3 · 3.6Caroline Shatuik#4 · 3.3Simba#5 · 2.9Nectar#6 · 2.8
Waterproof✓✓✕✓✕✓
Zips on all six sides (bed bugs)✕✓✕✕✕✕
Certification you can check✕✓~Allergy UK only✕✕None stated✕
Nothing synthetic against your skin✕✕✓✕~Cotton top only✕
Washes at 60 degrees or more??✕?✕✓90 degrees
Under £40 for a double✓✓✕✓✕✕
✓ yes✕ no~ partly? not stated
The reviews, ranked

Good, not so good, and the score

Panda Bamboo Mattress Protector1
Best overall

Panda Bamboo Mattress Protector

£33.30 for a double
3.9

A comfortable fitted protector with the right kind of waterproof film, at a sane price.

Good
✓Waterproof TPU film, not vinyl
✓Stretch skirt stays put on deep mattresses
✓4.61 from 540 reviews, 4.59 at Dunelm
Not so good
✕Owners report a faint plastic rustle
✕No certificate number for fabric claims
✕Slippery surface, sheets can shift
See it at Panda London
Utopia Bedding Premium Waterproof Encasement2
Best on a budget

Utopia Bedding Premium Waterproof Encasement

£13.49 for a double
3.9

Ties for first at £13.49, and the only certification here that checks out.

Good
✓Only verifiable OEKO-TEX certificate here
✓Zipped on six sides, good for bed bugs
✓12,889 ratings averaging 4.5
Not so good
✕Must unzip whole mattress to wash
✕All polyester, so it sleeps warmer
✕Some owners say liquid got through
Check price at Amazon
Woolroom Deluxe Washable Wool Mattress Protector3
Cleanest pick

Woolroom Deluxe Washable Wool Mattress Protector

£119.99 for a double
3.6

Nothing synthetic against your skin, but it is not waterproof.

Good
✓Wool and organic cotton, nothing synthetic
✓Allergy UK seal verified on its register
✓4.91 from 707 reviews, highest here
Not so good
✕Not waterproof at all
✕No straps, owners say it wanders
✕99 per cent dust mite claim unsupported
See the Woolroom
Caroline Shatuik Waterproof Terry Protector4
Child's bed

Caroline Shatuik Waterproof Terry Protector

£10.99 for a double
3.3

The cheapest here and a fair pick for a child's bed, but its claims cannot be checked.

Good
✓£10.99, the cheapest here
✓Terry top muffles the film crinkle
✓4.5 from 11,392 ratings
Not so good
✕Certification claims have no certificate number
✕Unsealed skirt lets large spills through
✕Little published about the fabric
Check price at Amazon
Simba Quilted Performance Protector5
Comfort only

Simba Quilted Performance Protector

£109 for a double
2.9

A comfortable quilted layer, but it is not waterproof and costs eight times the Utopia.

Good
✓Comfortable cotton cover and fill
✓Silent, with no film to crinkle
✓Fits mattresses up to 40cm deep
Not so good
✕Not waterproof, liquid poured straight through
✕£109 for comfort, not protection
✕Headline review count is brand-wide
See it at Simba
Nectar Mattress Protector6
Avoid

Nectar Mattress Protector

£45 for a double
2.8

Waterproof and hot-washable, but Nectar will not say what it is made of.

Good
✓Waterproof
✓Washes at 90 degrees, highest here
✓Two year warranty
Not so good
✕No fibre composition on UK site
✕Certification claims belong to a US product
✕Cannot be tumble dried, slow to dry
See it at Nectar
What we found

What the labels don’t tell you

1 of 6

publishes a certificate number that checks out on the certifier's register

£13.49

for the Utopia encasement that ties for first with the £33 Panda

£109

for the Simba protector, which is not waterproof at all

12%

of Nectar customers order the wrong size, according to Nectar

Before you buy

The 30 second check

1Check the film, polyurethane or TPU, not PVC or vinyl.
2Look up the certificate number, a logo without a number is just a claim.
3Check the wash temperature, you want 60 degrees if allergies are the reason.
4Measure the mattress depth, and buy a skirt deeper than that.
5Expect waterproof to be warmer, any film traps some heat.
How we scored these
Works 35%
Made of 25%
Value 15%
Everyday 15%
Honest 10%

Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.

4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.

Final verdict

Buy the Panda Bamboo at £33.30 for most beds, or the Utopia encasement at £13.49 for the most proof per pound. Skip the Nectar, which will not say what it is made of.

See our pick