The best fabric conditioners, compared
Six fabric conditioners compared on published ingredients, perfume and named allergens, preservatives, price per wash, and whether the brand tells you enough to compare at all.
Our pickWhich one should you buy?
Show me conditioners that are…
Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.
| Ranked by score | Bio-D#1 · 3.8 | Ecover#2 · 3.3 | Comfort#3 · 3.2 | Fairy#4 · 3.0 | Lenor#5 · 2.7 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No perfume | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ? |
| No added preservative | ✓Acidity preserves it | ✓Uses lactic acid | ✕Sodium benzoate | ? | ? | ? |
| Ingredients published online | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ |
| Wash count published | ✓ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ |
| Under 10p a wash | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ? |
Good, not so good, and the score
1Bio-D Fragrance Free Fabric Conditioner, 1L
The shortest declaration on the shelf: two ingredients, no perfume, no preservative.
£3.74 for a litre, 33 washes, about 11p a wash. The declaration is two lines long: 5 to 15 per cent cationic surfactant, under 5 per cent citric acid, pH 2.75. No perfume, no preservative, nothing else. On a shelf where the competition adds fragrance, allergens and a preservative, that is a different kind of product.
The low pH is doing double duty. It is what makes the cationic surfactant deposit properly on the fibre, and at 2.75 it also inhibits microbial growth, which is why there is no preservative to declare. That is a neater piece of formulating than anything else here manages.
It is Allergy UK certified, Vegan Society, Leaping Bunny and a B Corp, and made in Hull. One caveat we would rather flag than leave: Allergy UK’s own page for Bio-D names the laundry liquid, the washing powder and the nappy fresh, and does not name the fabric conditioner specifically. The claim may well be fine. We could not confirm it for this exact product.
Buy it if you want one and you want the shortest declaration on the shelf. Skip it if you were buying conditioner for the scent, because this has none by design.
2Ecover Fabric Softener, Apple Blossom and Almond, 1.43L
Publishes a real ingredient list and names its allergens, but hides the cost per wash.
£6.00 for 1.43 litres, and it publishes a proper list rather than the banded minimum: cationic surfactants, lactic acid, parfum with limonene, geraniol and geranyl acetate named, water, propylene glycol, lecithin and magnesium chloride. Naming the allergens is a legal duty above a threshold, but plenty of brands on this page have fragrance and name nothing, which tells you their perfume load sits under it.
Like Bio-D it uses an acid rather than a preservative, lactic in this case, and it has moved its cationic surfactant to a rapeseed oil base to get off palm. Leaping Bunny certified.
What stops it scoring higher is the arithmetic. The Tesco listing does not state a wash count, and different sources give different numbers for the same bottle, so we cannot tell you what a wash costs. On a 1.43 litre bottle at £6 that is somewhere between 13p and 17p, which would make it the most expensive here, and we are not going to publish an estimate as though it were a figure.
Buy it if you want the transparency and you are not counting pennies per wash. Skip it if you need to compare cost, because Ecover will not let you.
3Comfort Pure Sensitive Skin, 2.49L
The cheapest per wash and the least perfumed supermarket bottle.
£4.75 for 2.49 litres and 83 washes, which is 5.7p a wash and the best value on this page by a distance. The declaration is 5 to 15 per cent cationic surfactants, and under 5 per cent perfume, lactic acid and sodium benzoate.
It does contain perfume, and it names no allergens, which means the perfume load sits below the threshold at which they have to be listed. That is a meaningful difference from Lenor, which names eight. If somebody in the house reacts to laundry and you are not ready to give up conditioner entirely, this is the sensible supermarket choice.
What it will not tell you is what the cationic surfactant is. Nobody on this page will, but the claims stack up higher here than most: hypoallergenic, dermatologically tested, an association with the British Skin Foundation and a Mumsnet rating, and not one certificate or reference number behind any of it. Hypoallergenic in particular is not a defined term in UK law. It means the formulator aimed to reduce the chance of a reaction. It is not a test anybody passed.
Buy it if you want a conditioner, you shop in a supermarket and you want the least perfumed one there. Skip it if you expected hypoallergenic to mean something had been certified.
4Fairy Fabric Conditioner for Sensitive Skin, 2.635L
A big brand that warns about children's nightwear, but says little about its ingredients.
£6.00 for the 2.635 litre pack and 85 washes, about 7p a wash, 5 out of 5 from 1,949 reviews on Waitrose, and endorsed by the Skin Health Alliance. It is the bottle most people reach for when a baby arrives.
It earns a mark from us for something the others do not do. Printed on its own pack: do not use on children’s sleepwear or flame resistant garments, as it may reduce flame resistance. That is the manufacturer telling you the fatty layer it deposits is itself flammable and can interfere with a flame retardant treatment. UK children’s nightwear sold under the Nightwear Safety Regulations 1985 carries a label telling you to check the suitability of your washing agent, and this is what that label means. Fairy says it out loud. Most do not.
The declaration is thinner than the warning. Five to 15 per cent cationic surfactants and perfumes, no allergens named, no preservative named at all. And as with Comfort, the sensitive skin positioning rests on a product that contains fragrance.
Buy it if you want a big brand and you will heed the nightwear warning. Skip it if you are washing a lot of sportswear or children’s pyjamas, because it says not to.
5Lenor Fabric Conditioner, 2.64L
Delivers the scent, with the heaviest declared fragrance allergen load on the page.
£5.97 for 2.64 litres and 85 washes, about 7p a wash, and it is the most heavily perfumed thing on this page by its own declaration. Under 5 per cent cationic surfactants, then perfumes, then amyl salicylate, citronellol, coumarin, dimethyl phenethyl acetate, eugenol, geraniol, hexyl cinnamal, linalool, patchouli oil and a synthetic musk.
Naming those is compliance rather than carelessness. Above 0.01 per cent in a rinse off product they have to be listed, so a brand naming eight of the 26 declarable allergens is being straight with you about a perfume load that is genuinely high. Comfort names none, which tells you its load sits under the line.
That is the whole verdict really. If the scent is the reason you buy conditioner then Lenor is doing the job you are paying for and doing it well. If anybody in the house has reactive skin or eczema, this is the bottle on the page most likely to be the cause, and fragrance rather than anything else is the ingredient class dermatology associates with contact reactions from laundry.
Buy it if the smell is the entire point and nobody in the house reacts to anything. Skip it if anybody in the house has eczema or reactive skin.
Almat So Soft Premium (Aldi), 1.05L
The cheapest bottle, but Aldi publishes nothing about what is in it.
£1.79 for 1.05 litres, and it is last for one reason. Aldi publishes no ingredient information for it online at all. The product page says to read the label in store. There is no wash count either, so we cannot work out a price per wash, and the community ingredient databases have the barcode with the list left blank.
We are not marking it down for being cheap. The Aldi laundry range has taken Which? awards and their non bio liquid is the best value thing on our detergents page. We are marking it down because a shopper who wants to know what is in a product they put on their bedding and their children’s clothes cannot find out without standing in the aisle with the bottle in their hand.
It may well be a perfectly good conditioner with an unremarkable declaration. We have no way of telling you, and neither has anybody else, and on a site whose whole basis is reading what is in things, that has to come last.
Buy it if you are in Aldi, you are price led, and you will read the bottle in the aisle. Skip it if you want to know what you are buying before you leave the house.
What the labels don’t tell you
declared ingredients in Bio-D Fragrance Free, with no perfume and no preservative
fragrance allergens named on Lenor, the most on the page
a wash, a threefold spread you cannot see from the shelf
do not publish a wash count at all
The 30 second check
How we scored these
Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.
4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.
Most households need none. If you want one, buy Bio-D Fragrance Free at about 11p a wash, or Comfort Pure at under 6p. Skip the Aldi Almat, which publishes no ingredients.