Home · Cleaning · Eco and non-toxic

The best eco cleaning spray refills, compared

Six refill concentrates for surface sprays, compared on published ingredients, preservatives, fragrance disclosure, cost per 500ml made up, plastic and what owners say about cleaning.

By Mrs HouseUpdated October 20266 products compared
smol Multi Purpose Surface Spray refill tabletsOur pick
4.1
smol Multi Purpose Surface Spray refill tablets
£7 for 6 tablets, £1.17 per 500ml
✓Every ingredient named on its site
✓No preservative in the published list
✓£1.17 per 500ml bottle
The 10 second answer

Which one should you buy?

Side by side

Show me cleaning spray refills that are…

Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.

Ranked by scoresmol#1 · 4.1Ecover#2 · 3.8Spruce#3 · 3.7OceanSaver#4 · 3.6Iron & Velvet#5 · 3.4Neat#6 · 3.3
Full ingredient list published✓✓~surfactant not named~bands only~bands only~types only
No harsh disinfectant✓✓✓✓✕~unnamed cationic surfactant
No MIT or BIT preservatives listed✓✓✓✓?preservative not stated✓
Fragrance allergens named✓✓~may contain✓✓✓
Refill packaging plastic-free✓✕recycled plastic bottle✓✓✓?
Under £1.50 per 500ml made up✓✕✕£1.75 on bundle✓✕✕
✓ yes✕ no~ partly? not stated
The reviews, ranked

Good, not so good, and the score

smol Multi Purpose Surface Spray refill tablets1
Best overall

smol Multi Purpose Surface Spray refill tablets

£7 for 6 tablets, £1.17 per 500ml
4.1

Full ingredients, no preservative listed, plastic-free refills and one of the lowest costs per bottle here.

Good
✓Every ingredient named on its site
✓No preservative in the published list
✓£1.17 per 500ml bottle
Not so good
✕Subscription only, posted by letterbox
✕Contains colourant and added perfume
✕One owner reports streaks on glass
Works4.0
Made of4.0
Value4.3
Everyday3.8
Honest4.5
See it at smol
Ecover Multi-Action Surface Cleaner Refill Concentrate, 150ml2
Best in shops

Ecover Multi-Action Surface Cleaner Refill Concentrate, 150ml

£5 for 150ml at Ocado, £1.67 per 500ml
3.8

Full ingredient list and easy to find, but the refill is still a plastic bottle.

Good
✓Full ingredient list on its site
✓Refills any spray bottle you own
✓Sold in mainstream supermarkets
Not so good
✕Refill bottle is still plastic
✕Uses phenoxyethanol as a preservative
✕One owner reports streaks on hobs
Works3.5
Made of3.8
Value3.8
Everyday4.0
Honest4.5
See it at Ocado
Spruce Multipurpose Refills, Geranium, 3 pack3
Best compostable

Spruce Multipurpose Refills, Geranium, 3 pack

£9.99 for 3 refills, £3.33 per 500ml
3.7

Food-grade preservatives and compostable paper sachets, but dear unless you buy twelve.

Good
✓Food-grade preservatives, no synthetic fragrance
✓Home compostable paper refill sachets
✓Scented with organic geranium oil
Not so good
✕£3.33 per bottle on a 3 pack
✕Surfactant named only as plant-derived
✕Owners say weaker in hard water
Works3.6
Made of4.3
Value3.0
Everyday3.6
Honest3.6
See it at Spruce
OceanSaver Multi-Purpose Cleaner EcoDrop, 10ml4
Best on a budget

OceanSaver Multi-Purpose Cleaner EcoDrop, 10ml

£1.75 per drop at Ocado (£1.16 on offer), £1.17 per 500ml
3.6

Cheap per bottle and sold in supermarkets, though only allergens are named in full.

Good
✓£1.17 per 500ml at full price
✓Paper packaging, no plastic bottle
✓No subscription, sold in supermarkets
Not so good
✕Ingredients given mostly as bands
✕Preservative is phenoxyethanol
✕Little detail on how well it cleans
Works3.4
Made of3.6
Value4.3
Everyday3.8
Honest2.8
See it at Ocado
Iron and Velvet Kitchen Antibac refill sachet, 500ml5
Best antibacterial

Iron and Velvet Kitchen Antibac refill sachet, 500ml

£2 per sachet, makes 500ml
3.4

Well rated and plastic-free, but it contains a harsh disinfectant and a long fragrance allergen list.

Good
✓Dissolving sachet, no plastic at all
✓Trustpilot 4.6 from 330 reviews
✓Names its disinfectant and allergens
Not so good
✕Contains harsh disinfectant (benzalkonium type)
✕Eight fragrance allergens listed
✕Ingredients given only as bands
Works3.8
Made of2.6
Value3.8
Everyday3.6
Honest3.0
See it at Iron and Velvet
Neat Concentrated Refill Multisurface Cleaner, Grapefruit, 30ml6
Weakest here

Neat Concentrated Refill Multisurface Cleaner, Grapefruit, 30ml

£2.50 at Tesco (£2 with Clubcard), makes 500ml
3.3

Easy to buy at Tesco, but vague ingredients and a corrosive concentrate.

Good
✓Sold at Tesco and Ocado
✓Tesco rating 4.9 from 13 reviews
✓Preservative and allergens are named
Not so good
✕Surfactant types listed, not named
✕Concentrate carries a corrosive warning
✕£2.50 per 500ml, dearer than most
Works3.5
Made of2.8
Value3.0
Everyday4.2
Honest2.6
See it at Tesco
What we found

What the labels don’t tell you

2 of 6

publish a full ingredient list naming every ingredient. The rest give percentage bands or class names.

£1.17

the lowest cost per 500ml made up, shared by smol tablets and the OceanSaver drop at full price.

1 of 6

lists a harsh disinfectant outright: Iron and Velvet Kitchen Antibac.

0 of 6

list the skin-sensitising preservatives MIT or BIT in what they publish.

Before you buy

The 30 second check

1Work out the cost per bottle, not per pack. Divide the price by how many 500ml bottles it makes. Here that ranges from £1.17 to £3.33.
2Look for a full ingredient list, not just percentage bands. Only two of the six here name every ingredient, smol and Ecover.
3Check for harsh disinfectant, listed as quaternary ammonium compounds or cationic surfactants. Everyday worktop cleaning rarely needs it.
4Read the fragrance allergens, such as linalool, limonene and citral. If you react to scent, look for the shortest list.
5Check what the refill comes in, because some are paper or dissolving sachets while others are still small plastic bottles.
How we scored these
Works 35%
Made of 25%
Value 15%
Everyday 15%
Honest 10%

Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.

4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.

Final verdict

smol is the pick: full ingredients, no preservative listed and £1.17 a bottle. OceanSaver matches it on price without a subscription. Neat is the weakest here, with unnamed surfactants and a corrosive concentrate.

See our pick