The best dining tables for four to six, compared
Six UK dining tables for four to six people, £129 to £2,695, compared on solid wood versus veneer, finishes, FSC claims, extending, care and price.
Our pickWhich one should you buy?
Show me dining tables that are…
Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.
| Ranked by score | IKEA SKOGSTA#1 · 4.2 | Oaklee#2 · 4.1 | ercol Windsor#3 · 4.1 | PINNTORP#4 · 4.1 | Dunelm Manila#6 · 3.1 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Solid wood top, not veneer | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ~says veneer top finish | ✕oak veneers |
| Extends for guests | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Seats six without extending | ✕ | ✓ | ~four to six | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Finish named, oil or lacquer | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✓ |
| FSC certified wood stated | ? | ? | ? | ? | ✓ | ? |
| Under £300 | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ |
Good, not so good, and the score
1IKEA SKOGSTA Dining Table, Round 120cm, Acacia/Black
A solid acacia round table for four with every material listed, at a fair price.
£299 at IKEA for a 120cm round table that seats four. The top is solid acacia with clear acrylic lacquer and the legs and rails are solid acacia with a black acrylic paint. There is no fibreboard or chipboard listed anywhere. IKEA says acacia is hard-wearing, resists scratches and water, and darkens slightly with age, and that light stains lift with a damp sponge or mild soapy water.
It wins because it is solid wood throughout, fully listed, and costs a quarter of the next solid table up. Owners rate it 4.4 from 51 reviews and call it solid, heavy and good looking, with a striking grain. If you need six seats, the longer SKOGSTA at £449 is the same wood and seats six to eight.
The catch: it seats four and does not extend. Owners say it takes a while to assemble and may be heavy for one person. IKEA asks you to re-tighten the screws when needed. Buy it for a family of four who want real wood that can be sanded back one day.
2Oak Furnitureland Oaklee Natural Oak Extendable Dining Table 160 to 210cm
100% solid oak with an oil finish and a butterfly leaf, for six that becomes eight.
£1,109.99 at Oak Furnitureland. The material is listed as 100% solid oak, treated with Soft Sheen Oil, and the table is 160cm long, extending to 210cm with a central butterfly leaf that folds away inside. Oak Furnitureland sells it as a 6 to 8 seater. It weighs 67.5kg and needs some home assembly.
It is the best extending table here because it is solid oak all through and costs well under half of ercol's. An oil finish soaks into the wood rather than sitting on top as a film, so small marks can be spot-repaired. Oak Furnitureland gives a lifetime guarantee on the structural frame, with terms.
The catch is care. Oak Furnitureland does not say on the page how often to re-oil or how to treat rings, so ask before you buy. There are no owner reviews on the listing to check for faults, and no FSC claim. Buy it if you host six to eight people regularly and want one table for decades.
3ercol Windsor Medium Extending Dining Table, Solid Ash
British-made solid ash that seats four to six and extends to eight, at a heirloom price.
From £2,695 at ercol. The construction is solid ash and the country of origin is the UK. Closed, it is 150cm long and seats four to six; open, it is 200cm and seats six to eight, with the extension leaf stored inside the table. It arrives fully assembled, weighs 44kg, and has 78cm between the legs.
ercol finishes it in your choice of ten lacquer colours, from whitened to black, which it says protect the timber and add to the richness of the wood. A lacquer film is easier to keep clean day to day than oil, though ercol does not describe what the lacquer is made of.
It ties with the Oaklee on score and loses on value: it costs over twice as much for a similar solid hardwood, extending table. There are no owner reviews on ercol's site, and delivery is quoted at 14 weeks. Buy it if British manufacture matters to you and you want a table to pass on.
4IKEA PINNTORP Table, 125 x 75cm, Light Brown/White Stained Pine
Solid pine for four at £129, with all materials listed and hundreds of happy owners.
£129 at IKEA for a 125 by 75cm table that seats four. IKEA lists solid pine for the top and the frame, with an adhesive, a stain, and clear acrylic lacquer. There is no fibreboard listed. It is tested for home use to EN 12521 and EN 1730, and IKEA says it can be separated for recycling.
Owners rate it 4.6 from 302 reviews. They call it sturdier than it looks, easy to clean with a toddler around, and good value. One says it is the right size for four at Christmas without crowding a small kitchen the rest of the year.
It is the budget pick rather than the winner because pine is a softwood, so it dents more easily than acacia or oak, and it neither seats six nor extends. One owner got two sets of leg instructions, which made assembly fiddly. Buy it for a small kitchen, a first home or as a desk.
Habitat Trezy Solid Wood 6 Seater Dining Table, Oak
A six-seater for £258 with an FSC claim, but a confusing solid or veneer description.
£258 at Habitat for a 150 by 85cm table that seats six. Habitat calls it solid oak and lists a solid wood table with solid wood legs, but also says it has a wood veneer table top finish. It weighs 49kg, needs two people to assemble, and comes with a two-year guarantee. It is the only table here whose listing states FSC certification.
For six seats it is the cheapest table here by a long way, at about £43 per place. Owners rate it 4.4 from seven reviews and describe it as solid, heavy and quick to assemble, with a ridged leg detail that stands out. One says it oozes quality and that matching benches are available in the same design.
It ranks fifth because the listing contradicts itself on whether the top is solid oak or veneer, which matters if you ever want to sand it. Habitat does not name the finish. One owner returned theirs after finding chips, dark green marks and an area that looked painted over. Buy it if six seats on a budget matter most, and inspect it on delivery.
6Dunelm Cedar & Sage Manila 6 Seater Dining Table, Oak
A striking chevron top, but billed as solid oak while built with veneers, at a high price.
£689 at Dunelm for a six-seater. The first bullet calls it a solid oak dining table, but the description says it is made using European oak and rustic oak structured veneers, laid in a chevron inlay and finished in a matt lacquer. The composition line just says oak. Dunelm does not say what the veneer is glued to.
Owners rate it 4.3 from three reviews. One says the quality is exceptional and the pattern beautiful. Another found it about 3cm taller than they were used to, so their chairs felt low. A third says it marks with water just from wiping the surface down.
It ranks last because it costs more than double Habitat's six-seater, is described inconsistently, and a veneer top cannot be sanded back like the solid tables here. If you love the chevron, check the height against your chairs and ask Dunelm exactly what sits under the veneer.
What the labels don’t tell you
have solid wood tops: IKEA SKOGSTA and PINNTORP, Oak Furnitureland Oaklee and ercol Windsor.
states FSC certified wood on the listing: Habitat Trezy.
buys IKEA PINNTORP, a solid pine table for four rated 4.6 by 302 owners.
extend for guests, and both cost over £1,000.
The 30 second check
How we scored these
Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.
4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.
IKEA SKOGSTA wins for four: solid acacia for £299. PINNTORP is the £129 budget pick, Oak Furnitureland Oaklee the best extending table. Dunelm Manila is weakest, sold as solid oak but built with veneers.