Home · Kitchen · Tables, chairs and bar stools

The best dining tables for four to six, compared

Six UK dining tables for four to six people, £129 to £2,695, compared on solid wood versus veneer, finishes, FSC claims, extending, care and price.

By Mrs HouseUpdated October 20266 products compared
IKEA SKOGSTA Dining Table, Round 120cm, Acacia/BlackOur pick
4.2
IKEA SKOGSTA Dining Table, Round 120cm, Acacia/Black
£299 at IKEA
✓Solid acacia top and legs
✓Acacia resists scratches and water, says IKEA
✓Rated 4.4 by 51 owners
The 10 second answer

Which one should you buy?

Side by side

Show me dining tables that are…

Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.

Ranked by scoreIKEA SKOGSTA#1 · 4.2Oaklee#2 · 4.1ercol Windsor#3 · 4.1PINNTORP#4 · 4.1Habitat Trezy#5 · 3.7Dunelm Manila#6 · 3.1
Solid wood top, not veneer✓✓✓✓~says veneer top finish✕oak veneers
Extends for guests✕✓✓✕✕✕
Seats six without extending✕✓~four to six✕✓✓
Finish named, oil or lacquer✓✓✓✓✕✓
FSC certified wood stated????✓?
Under £300✓✕✕✓✓✕
✓ yes✕ no~ partly? not stated
The reviews, ranked

Good, not so good, and the score

IKEA SKOGSTA Dining Table, Round 120cm, Acacia/Black1
Best overall

IKEA SKOGSTA Dining Table, Round 120cm, Acacia/Black

£299 at IKEA
4.2

A solid acacia round table for four with every material listed, at a fair price.

Good
✓Solid acacia top and legs
✓Acacia resists scratches and water, says IKEA
✓Rated 4.4 by 51 owners
Not so good
✕Seats four, not six
✕Does not extend
✕Heavy, slow assembly, say owners
Works4.2
Made of4.4
Value4.2
Everyday3.9
Honest4.3
See it at IKEA
Oak Furnitureland Oaklee Natural Oak Extendable Dining Table 160 to 210cm2
Best extending

Oak Furnitureland Oaklee Natural Oak Extendable Dining Table 160 to 210cm

£1,109.99 at Oak Furnitureland
4.1

100% solid oak with an oil finish and a butterfly leaf, for six that becomes eight.

Good
✓Listed as 100% solid oak
✓Oil finish, no plastic lacquer coat
✓Lifetime structural guarantee
Not so good
✕Over £1,100
✕Oiled tops need more care
✕No owner reviews on the page
Works4.2
Made of4.7
Value3.2
Everyday3.8
Honest3.9
See it at Oak Furnitureland
ercol Windsor Medium Extending Dining Table, Solid Ash3
Made in Britain

ercol Windsor Medium Extending Dining Table, Solid Ash

From £2,695 at ercol
4.1

British-made solid ash that seats four to six and extends to eight, at a heirloom price.

Good
✓Solid ash, made in the UK
✓Arrives fully assembled
✓Leaf stores inside the table
Not so good
✕£2,695, the dearest here
✕Delivery quoted at 14 weeks
✕Lacquer chemistry not described
Works4.4
Made of4.8
Value2.2
Everyday4.0
Honest4.2
See it at ercol
IKEA PINNTORP Table, 125 x 75cm, Light Brown/White Stained Pine4
Best on a budget

IKEA PINNTORP Table, 125 x 75cm, Light Brown/White Stained Pine

£129 at IKEA
4.1

Solid pine for four at £129, with all materials listed and hundreds of happy owners.

Good
✓Solid pine top and frame
✓Rated 4.6 by 302 owners
✓Compact 125 x 75cm for small kitchens
Not so good
✕Seats four only
✕Pine dents more easily than hardwood
✕Does not extend
Works3.8
Made of4.2
Value4.8
Everyday3.9
Honest4.3
See it at IKEA
Habitat Trezy Solid Wood 6 Seater Dining Table, Oak5
FSC, seats six

Habitat Trezy Solid Wood 6 Seater Dining Table, Oak

£258 at Habitat
3.7

A six-seater for £258 with an FSC claim, but a confusing solid or veneer description.

Good
✓Seats six for £258
✓FSC certified, says Habitat
✓Two-year guarantee
Not so good
✕Listing says solid and veneer top
✕One owner returned it chipped
✕Only seven reviews
Works3.8
Made of3.6
Value4.2
Everyday3.6
Honest3.0
See it at Habitat
Dunelm Cedar & Sage Manila 6 Seater Dining Table, Oak6
Weakest here

Dunelm Cedar & Sage Manila 6 Seater Dining Table, Oak

£689 at Dunelm
3.1

A striking chevron top, but billed as solid oak while built with veneers, at a high price.

Good
✓Chevron oak pattern owners love
✓Matt lacquer, natural look
✓Seats six
Not so good
✕Called solid oak, uses oak veneers
✕Owner reports water marks from wiping
✕£689 with only three reviews
Works3.4
Made of3.2
Value2.6
Everyday3.2
Honest2.4
See it at Dunelm
What we found

What the labels don’t tell you

4 of 6

have solid wood tops: IKEA SKOGSTA and PINNTORP, Oak Furnitureland Oaklee and ercol Windsor.

1 of 6

states FSC certified wood on the listing: Habitat Trezy.

£129

buys IKEA PINNTORP, a solid pine table for four rated 4.6 by 302 owners.

2 of 6

extend for guests, and both cost over £1,000.

Before you buy

The 30 second check

1Read the materials line, not the headline. Dunelm's Manila is billed as a solid oak table but the description says oak veneers. Habitat's Trezy says solid oak and a wood veneer top finish.
2Solid tops can be sanded back. Rings and scratches in solid acacia, oak, ash or pine can be sanded out and refinished. A thin veneer over fibreboard only allows a very light sand.
3Oil or lacquer. Oak Furnitureland oils the Oaklee for a natural feel; IKEA and Dunelm use lacquer. Ask the seller how to treat rings and how often an oiled top needs re-oiling.
4Check the seating number and leg gap. Corner legs can block a chair. ercol lists a 78cm gap between the Windsor's legs; it seats four to six closed and six to eight extended.
5Look for FSC on the listing. Only Habitat states FSC certified wood here. If it matters to you, ask the others where their timber comes from.
How we scored these
Works 35%
Made of 25%
Value 15%
Everyday 15%
Honest 10%

Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.

4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.

Final verdict

IKEA SKOGSTA wins for four: solid acacia for £299. PINNTORP is the £129 budget pick, Oak Furnitureland Oaklee the best extending table. Dunelm Manila is weakest, sold as solid oak but built with veneers.

See our pick