Home · Bedroom · Bedroom storage

The best chests of drawers, compared

Six chests of drawers from £49 to £465, compared on solid wood versus MDF, anti-tip fittings, drawer runners, finishes and price, using maker listings and owner reviews.

By Mrs HouseUpdated October 20266 products compared
Oak Furnitureland Canterbury Natural Solid Oak 3+2 Chest of DrawersOur pick
4.3
Oak Furnitureland Canterbury Natural Solid Oak 3+2 Chest of Drawers
£349.99
✓Oak drawer backs, bases and runners
✓Dovetail drawer joints
✓Arrives assembled, lifetime structural guarantee
The 10 second answer

Which one should you buy?

Side by side

Show me chests of drawers that are…

Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.

Ranked by scoreCanterbury#1 · 4.3IKEA HEMNES#2 · 4.2Habitat Radius#3 · 3.9IKEA RAST#4 · 3.9IKEA VIHALS#5 · 3.8Lynton#6 · 3.3
Main body is solid wood✓✓~oak and oak veneer✓✕particleboard✕MDF and particleboard
Wall fixings in the box?✓✓?✓plus one-drawer lock?
Drawer boxes solid wood✓~fibreboard bottoms?~fibreboard bottoms✕✕
Runners named on the listing✓oak~pull-out stop only✓soft-close metal✕✕✓full extension
Guarantee over one year✓lifetime, structural?✕???
Under £200✕✓✕✓✓✓
✓ yes✕ no~ partly? not stated
The reviews, ranked

Good, not so good, and the score

Oak Furnitureland Canterbury Natural Solid Oak 3+2 Chest of Drawers1
Best overall

Oak Furnitureland Canterbury Natural Solid Oak 3+2 Chest of Drawers

£349.99
4.3

Solid oak including drawer backs, bases and runners, delivered assembled. Anti-tip fittings are not mentioned.

Good
✓Oak drawer backs, bases and runners
✓Dovetail drawer joints
✓Arrives assembled, lifetime structural guarantee
Not so good
✕Wall fixings not mentioned
✕Finish type not named
✕49kg, heavy to move
Works4.4
Made of4.9
Value3.8
Everyday4.2
Honest3.4
See it at Oak Furnitureland
IKEA HEMNES Chest of 3 Drawers, White Stain2
Best value

IKEA HEMNES Chest of 3 Drawers, White Stain

£199
4.2

Solid pine with a wall-anchoring kit in the box and 190 litres of storage, for £199.

Good
✓Solid pine frame and drawer sides
✓Wall-anchoring kit included
✓Rated 4.4 out of 5 by 882
Not so good
✕Fibreboard back and inner sides
✕Stained and lacquered, not bare wood
✕Flat pack, assembly needed
Works4.3
Made of4.1
Value4.2
Everyday3.8
Honest4.6
See it at IKEA
Habitat Radius 3 Drawer Chest, Oak3
Soft-close oak

Habitat Radius 3 Drawer Chest, Oak

£465
3.9

Solid oak and veneer with soft-close metal runners and wall fixings, but pricey with a one-year guarantee.

Good
✓Solid oak and oak veneer
✓Soft-close metal runners
✓Wall fixings included
Not so good
✕Most expensive chest here
✕Only a one-year guarantee
✕Just 8 owner reviews
Works4.0
Made of4.3
Value2.9
Everyday4.0
Honest3.8
See it at Habitat
IKEA RAST Chest of 3 Drawers, Pine4
Best on a budget

IKEA RAST Chest of 3 Drawers, Pine

£49
3.9

Untreated solid pine for £49, easy to paint or refinish. Drawers only open part way.

Good
✓Untreated solid pine for £49
✓Low 59cm height, less tip risk
✓Easy to sand, oil or paint
Not so good
✕Drawers open only about two thirds
✕Small: 46 litres of storage
✕One owner says the price doubled
Works3.4
Made of4.2
Value4.8
Everyday3.2
Honest4.4
See it at IKEA
IKEA VIHALS Chest of 4 Drawers, White, Anchor and Unlock5
Safest for children

IKEA VIHALS Chest of 4 Drawers, White, Anchor and Unlock

£129
3.8

Particleboard throughout, but only one drawer opens until it is fixed to the wall.

Good
✓One drawer at a time until anchored
✓Wall-anchoring kit included
✓Rated 4.4 out of 5 by 198
Not so good
✕Particleboard throughout, no solid wood
✕Acrylic paint and plastic edging
✕One owner found instructions hard
Works4.1
Made of2.6
Value4.0
Everyday4.4
Honest4.6
See it at IKEA
Dunelm Lynton 5 Drawer Chest6
Weakest here

Dunelm Lynton 5 Drawer Chest

£179, reduced from £219
3.3

MDF and chipboard with smooth full-extension runners, but no word on anti-tip fittings.

Good
✓Full-extension drawer runners
✓Five drawers, three large
✓Material split published
Not so good
✕56% MDF, 44% particleboard
✕Wall fixings not mentioned
✕Lacquer type not stated
Works3.7
Made of2.4
Value3.5
Everyday3.8
Honest2.8
See it at Dunelm
What we found

What the labels don’t tell you

93%

of US child tip-over deaths from 2000 to 2018 involved children five and under, says the US product safety regulator.

3 of 6

listings say a wall-anchoring kit or wall fixings come in the box.

1 of 6

chests stops more than one drawer opening until it is fixed to the wall: IKEA's VIHALS.

£49

buys IKEA's RAST in untreated solid pine, the cheapest chest here.

Before you buy

The 30 second check

1Fix it to the wall. In the US, 93% of child tip-over deaths recorded from 2000 to 2018 were children aged five and under. Use the fittings, or buy a wall strap.
2Check the fittings are in the box. Only three of these six listings say a wall-anchoring kit or wall fixings are included. Ask before you buy the others.
3Look at the drawer box, not just the front. Solid wood fronts often hide fibreboard backs and bottoms. The best chests here use solid wood for drawer sides and runners.
4Know your runners. Wooden runners are simple and repairable but can stick. Metal full-extension runners open all the way and run smoothly.
5Read the material split. "56% MDF, 44% particleboard" means no solid wood at all. Both are wood fibres or chips held together with glue.
How we scored these
Works 35%
Made of 25%
Value 15%
Everyday 15%
Honest 10%

Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.

4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.

Final verdict

Oak Furnitureland's Canterbury is the best made, oak down to the runners, but fix it to the wall yourself. IKEA's HEMNES is the best value. Dunelm's Lynton, all MDF and chipboard, is the weakest.

See our pick