Home · Living room · Floors

The best carpet cleaning solutions, compared

Six carpet machine solutions compared on what they publish (dilution ratio, pH, ingredients), wool safety, cost per tank, leftover residue and whether the warranty threats hold up.

By Mrs HouseUpdated October 20266 products compared
1001 Carpet Machine Solution, 1 litreOur pick
3.7
1001 Carpet Machine Solution, 1 litre
£3.00 for 1 litre
✓Full ingredients, ratio and pH published
✓WoolSafe approved
✓States no optical brighteners
The 10 second answer

Which one should you buy?

Side by side

Show me solutions that are…

Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.

Ranked by score1001#1 · 3.7Rug Doctor#2 · 3.2Vax Ultra+#3 · 3.0Bissell#4 · 2.9Dr. Beckmann#5 · 2.7Ecozone#6 · 2.5
Dilution ratio published✓~coverage only✕fill line only✕fill line only?spot product✕
WoolSafe approved✓✕✓✕✕✕
pH published✓✕✕✕✕✕
Full ingredient list published✓✕✕✕~reasonable range info✕
Under £10 a bottle✓✕✕✕✓✓
✓ yes✕ no~ partly? not stated
The reviews, ranked

Good, not so good, and the score

1001 Carpet Machine Solution, 1 litre1
Best overall

1001 Carpet Machine Solution, 1 litre

£3.00 for 1 litre
3.7

The £3 bottle that tells you more than any rival, and it is WoolSafe approved.

Good
✓Full ingredients, ratio and pH published
✓WoolSafe approved
✓States no optical brighteners
Not so good
✕pH 8 to 9, near wool's limit
✕Machine brands may dispute your guarantee
✕General solution, not tuned to machines
See 1001
Rug Doctor Carpet Detergent, 4 litres2
Most honest warranty

Rug Doctor Carpet Detergent, 4 litres

£24.99 for 4 litres
3.2

The machine brand with an honest warranty, best kept to synthetic carpets.

Good
✓Warranty says recommended, not required
✓Coverage published, 38 square metres a litre
✓About £2.79 a room on 4 litres
Not so good
✕Not WoolSafe approved
✕No pH published
✕No full ingredient list
See Rug Doctor
Vax Ultra+ Carpet Cleaning Solution, 1.5 litres3
WoolSafe approved

Vax Ultra+ Carpet Cleaning Solution, 1.5 litres

£22.99 for 1.5 litres
3.0

WoolSafe approved, but pricey, and its warranty warning does not hold up.

Good
✓WoolSafe approved
✓Low foam for Vax machines
✓4 litre is 40 to 43% cheaper
Not so good
✕Guide says others will invalidate guarantee
✕No ratio, pH or ingredient list
✕Most expensive per litre here
See it at Vax
Bissell Wash & Protect Carpet Formula, 1.5 litres4
Contradicts itself

Bissell Wash & Protect Carpet Formula, 1.5 litres

£16.00 for 1.5 litres
2.9

Bissell's own website undercuts its warranty warning, and little is published.

Good
✓Bissell says it is safe in rival machines
✓Cheaper than the Vax equivalent
✓Sound warning about lemon and pine oils
Not so good
✕Manuals and website contradict each other
✕Not WoolSafe approved
✕No ratio, pH or ingredient list
See it at CleanStore
Dr. Beckmann Carpet Stain Remover, 650ml5
Spot use only

Dr. Beckmann Carpet Stain Remover, 650ml

£4.00 for 650ml
2.7

A handy spot remover for synthetic carpets, not a machine solution.

Good
✓Built in brush head for spot marks
✓Cheap at £4.00 for 650ml
✓One review under three stars of 130
Not so good
✕Contains oxygen bleach
✕Excludes silk, so risky on wool
✕Spot use only, not whole rooms
See it at Robert Dyas
Ecozone Carpet Shampoo, 1 litre6
Avoid

Ecozone Carpet Shampoo, 1 litre

£9.99 for 1 litre
2.5

Plant based, but it publishes the least here at more than the winner's price.

Good
✓Plant based surfactants
✓Recyclable packaging, cruelty free
✓Cheaper than machine brand solutions
Not so good
✕No ratio, pH or full ingredient list
✕£9.99 a litre against £3 for 1001
✕Not WoolSafe approved
Check price at Amazon
What we found

What the labels don’t tell you

1 of 6

solutions here publish a full ingredient list, a real dilution ratio and a pH figure

4 of 6

publish no dilution ratio at all, so you cannot compare cost per tank

40 to 43%

cheaper per litre for the Vax 4 litre bottle than the 1.5 litre, for the same liquid

Before you buy

The 30 second check

1Find the dilution ratio. Without one, the bottle price tells you nothing about cost per tank.
2Check the pH for wool. Wool is damaged by alkaline solutions above about pH 8.5.
3Look up the WoolSafe directory. Logos are not listings, so check the directory yourself.
4Use less and rinse with clean water. Detergent left in the pile attracts dirt and makes carpet resoil faster.
5Keep lemon and pine oils out of the machine. They can attack the plastic, whoever made the bottle.
How we scored these
Works 35%
Made of 25%
Value 15%
Everyday 15%
Honest 10%

Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.

4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.

Final verdict

Buy the 1001 Carpet Machine Solution at £3, or Rug Doctor if you want a machine brand with an honestly written warranty. Skip Ecozone, which publishes the least here.

See our pick