The best carpet cleaners, compared
Six carpet washers compared on how much water they leave behind: extraction, suction only drying, tank sizes, how easy a plain water rinse is, weight and price.
Which one should you buy?
The only one where a plain water rinse is easy.

Refurbished from £149.99, and the fastest drying here.
The best hand tools, including a proper stair tool.

No brush bar, so it will not lift matted pile.
Show me machines that are…
Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.
| Ranked by score | Rug Doctor#2 · 4.5 | Kärcher#6 · 3.9 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plain water rinse without emptying the tank | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓plain water is default |
| Powered brush bar | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ |
| Fine with plain water or your own solution | ~own solution risks guarantee | ✓ | ? | ✕two Shark formulas | ? | ✓ |
| Dirty tank at least as big as clean | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ |
| Under 9kg | ✓ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✓ |
| Under £200 new | ✓ | ✕£149.99 refurbished | ✕ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ |
Good, not so good, and the score
Vax Platinum SmartWash CDCW-SWXS
The only machine here that makes a plain water rinse pass easy.
The thing that wins it is a third tank. On every other machine on this page the detergent goes into the clean water tank, which means a rinse pass involves stopping halfway through, emptying the tank, refilling it with plain water and doing the whole room again. On this one the solution has its own reservoir and gets mixed in automatically, so you take it out or empty it and the machine sprays nothing but what you put in the water tank. That is a genuine clean water rinse, and it is the single most useful feature on any of these.
Why that matters more than it sounds: everything you put into a carpet has to come back out. Surfactant left in the pile stays slightly tacky and attracts soil, which is why a badly rinsed carpet looks dirty again in days rather than months. The professional trade answer is a rinse pass. Domestic machines almost never make that easy. This one does.
It also has a dedicated Dry Only suction mode, and Motion Sense means it washes as you push forward and switches to suction as you pull back, so the drying stroke is built into normal use rather than being something you have to remember. A verified buyer put it better than the marketing does, writing that the separate dry mode is excellent and leaves the carpet almost dry. An independent tester of the Pet-Design sibling reported carpets only lightly damp after cleaning.
On drying time, Vax claim as little as an hour on Dry Only. Trusted Reviews were more conservative and found that after a full wet clean the carpet still needed a few more hours. Take the conservative number. Either way it is comfortably inside the 24 hour window on a normal synthetic pile in a ventilated room, which is the only thing that actually matters.
The reservations are real. It is loud, measured at 84 decibels, which one tester compared to city traffic. The dirty water tank is only 1.9 litres against a 3.5 litre clean tank, so on a filthy room you empty it more often than you refill. It is bulky to store. And Vax solution runs about £45 for four litres, which is a real running cost.
One honest note on the brand. Vax attracts a run of complaints about poor suction, but read them carefully and they are almost all aimed at the cheap Vax washers rather than this one. We are not going to hold those against the Platinum, but you should know they exist before you buy a budget Vax on the strength of this review.
Buy it if you want the machine that makes it easiest to leave nothing behind in the carpet. Skip it if noise matters, or you want to run your own solution without a warranty question.
2Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner
Extracts hardest and dries fastest, but it is heavy with a short warranty.
If the thing that frightens you is a carpet still damp the next evening, this is the machine. Thirteen hundred air watts of suction, dual cross action brushes that oscillate rather than simply spinning, and a 4.2 litre recovery tank that is bigger than its own clean tank so you almost never stop mid room to empty it. An independent tester measured drying at about four hours in normal mode, which is the fastest verified real world figure of the six.
What we like just as much is the method Rug Doctor publish, because it is over wetting prevention baked in. Their own instructions say the machines are designed for one pass only, and tell you to release the spray button before the end of each run and keep vacuuming, so every stroke finishes on suction alone. If you have already over wet an area, their guidance is to release the spray button and do vacuum only passes. That is a manufacturer telling you how to un-flood a carpet, and none of the others do it.
It is also the machine for anyone who wants control over the chemistry. There is no separate detergent tank, which sounds like a downside, but it means the machine has no chemistry lock at all. It sprays whatever is in the tank. Official dosing is 150ml of their detergent to a tankful. Fill it with plain hot water instead and it will not know or care.
Two warnings on water temperature that people get wrong. Hot tap water is specified for synthetic carpets and it genuinely helps, both on cleaning and on evaporation. But Rug Doctor specifically say to use only lukewarm water on wool, because hot water shrinks wool. If you have a wool or wool blend carpet, which a lot of British housing stock does, read that twice.
The downsides are physical. It weighs 14.25kg empty and one tester called it very heavy and not the smoothest to manoeuvre. Getting it up a staircase is a two handed job and you should think about that before ordering. It is loud, which is the single most common owner complaint. And the warranty is weak for the money at two years new, one year nearly new and three months refurbished.
On that last point, the refurbished route is worth knowing about. Rug Doctor sell the same machine refurbished from £149.99, against £319.99 new. For a machine you will use three or four times a year, that is a sensible way in, as long as you accept the three month cover.
Buy it if drying speed is your top priority, or you want to run your own solution and buy refurbished. Skip it if you have stairs to carry it up, or you want a long warranty.
Bissell ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro 20666
Best for stairs and upholstery, but it puts down a lot of water.
The best hand tool set here by a distance. A genuine 3-in-1 stair tool, a 2-in-1 pet upholstery tool and a tough stain tool, all on a detachable 2.1 metre spot cleaning hose. Owners specifically single out how well it does stairs, which is where most carpet washers are useless.
Express Clean mode is the headline. Bissell claim carpets dry in 30 minutes on it, which is the fastest published drying claim in this group, and an independent test repeated that figure. Treat it as what it is: a manufacturer claim for a light refresh rather than a deep clean.
HeatWave is worth explaining precisely, because the marketing invites you to misread it. It maintains the temperature of the water you put in rather than letting it cool during the job. It is a heat maintainer, not a boiler. Warm water evaporates faster than cold, which genuinely helps drying. It does not sanitise anything and nobody should tell you otherwise.
Now the thing that keeps it third on our criteria. There is no separate solution tank, so a rinse pass means stopping, emptying the clean tank, refilling it with plain warm water and doing the room again. That is real friction, and friction is why people skip the rinse.
And there is a second issue that compounds it. This is the machine owners say lays down the most water. One buyer noted it dispenses at a higher rate and needs much more regular refills than the machine they replaced. More water in means more to get back out, and it makes the rinse question matter more, not less. Our advice: use Express Clean for maintenance, and on a deep clean do at least two suction only passes for every wet pass.
Otherwise it is well liked and well built. Currys rate it 4.8 from 328 reviews, one owner reported their previous Bissell ProHeat lasted twenty years, and it carries a six year guarantee. The complaints are that it is heavy to carry upstairs, that it struggled on really tough stains despite the power, and that the seven metre cable is the shortest here.
Buy it if you have a lot of stairs and upholstery and you want the tools to do them properly. Skip it if you want an easy rinse pass, or your carpets are somewhere slow to dry.
Shark CarpetXpert EX200UK with StainStriker
Handy for rooms, stairs and sofa spots, but not the driest and not for wool.
The StainStriker handheld is built into this machine rather than bolted on, so switching from cleaning a room to attacking a spot on the stairs or the sofa takes a lever and nothing else. No assembling anything, no hunting for a tool. Trusted Reviews called the conversion seamless and rated the tool range as excellent.
The feature we like most is one almost nobody mentions. Setting the mode lever horizontal flushes the hose head through with solution. That is a hose self clean function, and it matters because the recovery hose is the single filthiest part of any of these machines and the part nobody ever cleans. Nothing else at this price does it.
It is also the lightest full size upright here at 8.3kg and the smallest to store, it carries a five year guarantee on registration, and the review pools are strong, with 4.8 out of 5 from 831 reviews at one retailer and 310 at another.
Now the bad news, and on this page it is the news that counts. Trusted Reviews found it does not leave carpets the driest of the machines they tested, measuring the pile at 31 per cent humidity immediately after cleaning, with full drying within a couple of hours. That is still inside the safe window, but it is not class leading, and on a page about drying that costs it places.
The reason is probably the tank ratio, and it is the worst here by a long way. A 0.85 litre dirty tank against a 2.1 litre clean tank. Once the recovery tank fills, extraction drops off, and that is the classic cause of a machine that stops pulling water back out and leaves the carpet soaked. On anything bigger than a small room you will be emptying it constantly.
Two more things to know before you buy. Shark state it is not suitable for wool carpets, which is a hard exclusion and matters a lot given how much British housing has wool or wool blend carpet. And it is the most chemistry locked machine here, tied to a two part system of a Deep Clean base for the upright and an OXY Multiplier for the handheld.
Buy it if you want one machine that does rooms, stairs and sofa spots without swapping anything. Skip it if you have wool carpets, or a lot of floor area to cover before that tank fills.
Vax Platinum Power Max ECB1SPV1
Wide head and a big toolkit, but rinsing and drying are left to you.
The bigger, heavier sibling of our winner. A 35cm cleaning head, which is the widest here and means fewer passes to cover a room, the biggest tanks in the Vax range, and the best accessory bundle of the two: a SpinScrub hand tool, a dedicated upholstery tool and a pre treatment wand, which the SmartWash does not include. It also comes with a squeegee bar so it doubles as a hard floor washer.
Vax publish a how to page for this machine that is more useful than anything else any of these brands writes, and it applies to every machine on this page, so here it is. Make four or more slow forward passes with the trigger held. Then, in their words, to leave your carpets as dry as possible, use more dry passes, pulling back with the trigger released, than wet passes. And they warn you not to let your carpets get too wet. That is the single best over wetting instruction published by any manufacturer in this category.
Owners rate it. A Feefo product score of 4.7, buyers describing it clearing spilled noodles and red spice sauce, and multiple reviewers calling the value exceptional. Six year guarantee. Vax claim carpets dry in as little as an hour on the Quick Clean function, and one reviewer credited the suction with quicker drying carpets.
So why is it fifth and the SmartWash first? Because it has no separate solution tank. Vax own guidance is to fill the clean water tank with warm water at a maximum of 40 degrees plus cleaning solution, which means a rinse pass involves emptying and refilling. It also has no automatic dosing and no Motion Sense, so the wet and dry strokes are entirely down to you remembering to hold or release the trigger. On the SmartWash that is automatic.
The other complaints are weight and fiddliness. At 9.6kg it is the heaviest Vax, and one buyer described it as quite heavy to use though it does a thorough clean. More concerning, one owner complained that carpet fluff and hair could not be cleared without disassembly, calling it too plasticky with too many parts. Given how important the after use clean out is on these machines, that is a real mark against it.
One thing that applies to every machine here and that this one needs most: never pour kettle water in. Vax specify a maximum of 40 degrees into the tank. Hotter than that and you risk the plastics and the seals.
Buy it if you want the widest head and the fullest toolkit and you will do the dry passes yourself. Skip it if you want the rinse pass made easy, in which case buy the SmartWash instead.
6Kärcher SE 4 Select
Total freedom over what you spray, but no brush to lift matted pile.
If your reason for reading this page is that you do not want to pour a branded chemical into your carpet, this is your machine, and Kärcher are refreshingly blunt about why. Their own product description says tap water is simply sprayed fibre deep into textile surfaces under pressure and removed together with the dissolved dirt. You add detergent to the fresh water tank yourself, or you add nothing at all. Nothing in the machine cares.
It is also the most versatile thing here, because it is a cylinder rather than an upright and it doubles as a wet and dry vacuum. The nozzle set covers carpet, hard floor, upholstery, curtains, cushion covers, mattresses and car seats, and the 227mm head gets into corners, along skirtings and up stairs far better than a 30 to 35cm upright ever will. For upholstery and mattresses it is the best of the six.
The tanks are the best matched here at four litres each, so you never hit the situation where the recovery tank fills halfway through a room and extraction quietly stops. Kärcher UK offer up to a six year guarantee on registration.
And now the reason it is sixth, which is not a small thing. There is no powered brush bar. Nothing agitates the fibres. It sprays and it sucks. On matted, heavily trafficked pile it will not lift dirt the way a Rug Doctor or a Bissell does, and independent testing made exactly that criticism, along with finding it struggled with clumped wet dirt and pet hair.
That has a knock on effect that matters on this page. Without agitation you tend to make more passes to get the same result, and more passes means more water going down. So the machine that gives you the most chemical freedom also asks you to be the most careful about over wetting. Use the four litres of recovery capacity and do plenty of suction only passes.
Two practical notes. Testers found it fiddly to convert between wet and dry modes, and you must let the insides dry before switching back to dry vacuuming. And the UK model naming is a mess, with SE 4001, SE 4002, SE 4 Select and SE 5.100 all floating about, so check the order number rather than the name.
Buy it if you want to run plain hot water or your own solution, and you have a lot of upholstery. Skip it if your carpets are matted and heavily trafficked and need real agitation.
What the labels don’t tell you
the drying target, because mould can start on damp material within about 24 to 48 hours
machines has a separate detergent tank, so a plain water rinse needs no emptying and refilling
measured drying time for the Rug Doctor Deep, the fastest verified real world figure here
The 30 second check
How we scored these
Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.
4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.
Buy the Vax Platinum SmartWash for the easiest rinse and drying. Choose the Rug Doctor Deep if drying speed matters most. Skip the Kärcher if your carpets are matted and need a brush.