The best pillows, compared
Six pillows in wool, foam, latex, down and hollowfibre, compared on what they are made of, what they do for your neck and whether you can wash them.
Our pickWhich one should you buy?

No foam or polyester, adjustable, and washes at home.

£44.95 memory foam that holds its height.

Latex has the best clinical evidence for neck pain.

Polyester that compresses; buy it for washing, not comfort.
Show me pillows that are…
Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.
| Ranked by score | Woolroom#1 · 4.7 | Simba#2 · 4.6 | Dunlopillo#3 · 4.4 | Soak and Sleep#4 · 4.3 | Panda#5 · 4.0 | Silentnight#6 · 3.5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No polyurethane foam | ✓ | ✕ | ✓natural latex | ✓ | ✕ | ✓ |
| No polyester | ✓ | ✕ | ~cover varies | ✓ | ? | ✕ |
| Whole pillow washes at home | ✓ | ~not the foam core | ~cover only | ✕ | ~cover only | ✓ |
| Adjustable height | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ~pick when buying | ✕ | ✕ |
| Under £50 | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ |
Good, not so good, and the score
1Woolroom Deluxe Washable Wool Pillow
No foam or polyester, adjustable by the handful, and it washes at home.
The only pillow here with no polyurethane and no polyester anywhere in it. Five hundred and eighty grams of loose traceable British wool inside a zipped calico inner, plus another 300gsm of washable wool quilted into the cover itself, in a 200 thread count organic cotton case. No foam, no fibre, no down.
Because the fill is loose balls rather than a moulded block, you can tune it. Open the zip, pull handfuls out until the loft matches your shoulder, and stop. That makes it the only pillow here that works for a front sleeper as well as a side sleeper, because you can strip it right back. Reviewers rate that adjustment highly and one Best Buy award listed it as a headline strength.
It also washes at home, which almost no natural pillow at this level does. The cover unzips, the wool goes into the supplied calico bag, and the outer goes in the machine on a wool cycle at 40 degrees. That matters more than it sounds, and the dust mite section below explains why: washing is the single most effective mite intervention there is, and most good pillows cannot take it.
It scores well on comfort rather than just on credentials. Nine hundred and thirteen reviews on the product page run 88 per cent five star, one buyer with arthritis described it as like sinking into marshmallows, and an independent tester called it very comfortable with good support, medium to medium firm, dense rather than sink in. British Wool traceability to named farms, Allergy UK approval and OEKO-TEX Standard 100 on the cotton.
Now the complaints, and the first one is the consistent one. It smells of sheep when new. One tester recorded a slight sheepish smell on opening and one Trustpilot buyer said it took roughly six months of airing before they stopped noticing it. That is lanolin and wool grease rather than a solvent, so it is a very different thing from foam off-gassing, but it is real and you should know before you order.
The rest are practical. There is no spare fill in the box, so if you take wool out you have loose wool to store, and more costs £26 a bag. The zip has no pull tag and wool catches in the teeth, which one tester called awkward. And wool compacts, so it wants regular fluffing and occasional redistribution. One three star reviewer simply said it gives them neck ache, which is what happens if you leave the loft too high for your build. It cannot be tumble dried either, so washing it takes days.
Buy it if you want foam and polyester out of the thing your face is on, and you will fluff it. Skip it if a sheepy smell for the first few weeks would put you off it entirely.
2Simba Hybrid Pillow
Adjustable foam cubes and measured cooling suit side sleepers, but the foam core cannot be washed.
The most externally validated pillow in this comparison, with an aggregate 4.7 out of 5 from over 38,000 reviews and a run of UK awards behind it. You unzip it and pull foam Nanocubes out into a supplied bag until it fits you, and testers consistently say that adjustment is genuinely effective rather than a gimmick.
The cooling is measured rather than claimed, which we appreciate. One reviewer put a thermal camera on it and reported that the outline of the tester’s head had virtually disappeared after four minutes, and called it the best pillow they had ever used. The Stratos finish on the cover is a phase change material, which is a real mechanism rather than a marketing word.
Side sleeper support is the consistent praise from every UK outlet, and the cover and the fibre layers go in the machine at 40 degrees and can be tumble dried low, which is more washability than most premium pillows offer.
Now the materials, because this is a polyurethane pillow and we are going to treat it as one. The core is open cell visco-elastic polyurethane memory foam cut into cubes, wrapped in polyester fibre layers, a polyester inner cover and a polyester mesh border. Simba hold CertiPUR on the foam, which is real: it caps total VOC emissions and prohibits certain flame retardants, heavy metals, formaldehyde and phthalates. It does not mean zero emissions, it means emissions below a threshold.
One thing worth understanding about the cube design. Cutting foam into cubes massively increases the exposed surface area against a solid block. That is good for airflow, which is part of why it sleeps cool, and it is bad for the rate at which residual volatiles leave the material. In practice no UK tester reported an off-gassing smell, which is a meaningful signal, but the mechanism is there.
The practical complaints are consistent. Every single review lists the £109 price as the main con. It is too big for a standard pillowcase out of the box, with one tester calling the initial configuration almost too large to get into a regular case. It is wrong for front sleepers, being too lofty even at minimum fill. And the cubes misbehave: they go static while you adjust them, they shift slightly overnight so the feel changes by morning, and overstuffing can cause neck ache.
Buy it if you sleep on your side, you want it cool, and you want to dial the height in exactly. Skip it if you sleep on your front, or you are trying to keep polyurethane away from your face.
3Dunlopillo Super Comfort Latex Pillow
Latex is the fill with the best clinical evidence for easing neck pain, though the effect is modest.
If your reason for buying a new pillow is that your neck hurts, this is the fill type with actual clinical evidence behind it, and no other pillow on this page can say that. A 2021 systematic review and meta analysis of pillow designs found that rubber, meaning latex, pillows reduced neck pain with a standardised mean difference of minus 0.263 at p below 0.001, and that rubber and spring pillows reduced waking pain with a standardised mean difference of minus 0.228, across nine high quality studies and 555 participants.
That is a modest effect rather than a miracle, and we would rather give you the actual numbers than tell you a pillow will fix your neck. But it is more than exists for memory foam, for down or for hollowfibre, and it is why this sits third despite being the least fashionable thing here.
Verified buyers back it up. Feefo ratings run 4.6 out of 5 across 69 reviews, with one buyer with a neck injury saying it gives them the correct support they need. Multiple reviewers rated its suitability for allergy sufferers as exceptional, which makes sense: latex has a closed cell structure and the cover washes.
On materials it is a genuinely different proposition from the foam pillows. Natural latex is a plant polymer, not a polyurethane, so the polyurethane off-gassing pathway does not apply at all. It is moulded as one block by the Dunlop process, not shredded and not blended with memory foam. And it does not collapse: latex has the best recovery of any fill here, with a three year guarantee and the National Bed Federation approval mark. It also runs cooler than memory foam, because open cell pinned latex moves air in a way visco-elastic foam does not.
The complaints are specific. Latex has a characteristic ammonia and rubber smell. One Feefo reviewer said theirs always had a rubber smell, though another recorded no odour at all, so it seems to vary. It is heavy, two to three times the weight of a fibre pillow, which makes plumping and moving it a chore. And the height divides people: 17cm sounds tall but the latex compresses under load, so one buyer found it a little low and put a second pillow underneath while another wanted it firmer.
Two care points that matter. The core must never be machine washed, and it must never be dried in sunlight, because UV oxidises latex and it crumbles. Cover off at 40 degrees, and keep it out of a sunny window.
One thing to check before you buy. The composition wording varies by retailer, with some describing the cover as pure cotton and at least one as a cotton and polyester blend. Ask before you order if that matters to you. And note that no OEKO-TEX, GOLS or eco-INSTITUT certification is publicly stated on UK listings for this pillow, so do not assume any of them.
Buy it if you wake with neck pain and you want the fill type the research actually supports. Skip it if you sleep on your front, or you have a latex allergy.
4Soak and Sleep Hungarian Goose Down Pillow
Real 90 per cent goose down in a tight casing the mite research favours, but not home washable.
Ninety per cent Hungarian goose down to ten per cent feather, at 600 to 650 fill power, in a pure cotton cambric casing. That ratio is the thing to notice, because most high street pillows sold as goose down are 85 per cent feather with a token amount of down in them. This is the real article and it is priced accordingly at around £90 to £95.
The chambered versions fix the classic down problem. A supportive inner chamber inside a soft outer layer means it does not collapse flat under a heavy head the way single chamber down does, and you choose your loft at the point of purchase rather than adjusting later. Soft suits front sleepers, Soft/Medium suits back sleepers, Medium/Firm suits side sleepers.
And this is the pillow the dust mite literature is unexpectedly kindest to, which is the opposite of what most people assume. A 1999 study put paired new synthetic and feather pillows on twelve beds for twelve months and measured the main mite allergen at roughly three times higher on the synthetic pillows. A 2004 study explained the mechanism: electron microscopy put the pore size of synthetic casings at 57 micrometres against 18 micrometres for feather casings, mites crossed every standard synthetic casing within 24 hours but had not crossed feather casings after 48, and dust penetration was 0.88 per cent through synthetic against 0.07 per cent through feather. A 2006 study found the same direction for fungi.
The casing here is made to NOMITE specification, which exists because down cannot be contained by an ordinary weave. So the mite barrier is a matter of construction rather than of any added chemical, which is exactly the right way round.
On traceability it is well documented. Made to EN, Downpass and EDFA standards with STeP accreditation, washed in thermal spring water. Downpass audits for live plucking and force feeding, which is the question this audience will ask.
The drawbacks are real. It is expensive. It is wrong for front sleepers even in the soft version. Down needs plumping daily and it is not a home wash, and Soak and Sleep’s own comparison copy points buyers towards professional cleaning. Given that washing is the single best mite intervention, that is a genuine tension: the pillow with the lowest measured allergen load is also the one you cannot easily launder. And quills work through eventually, which is the standard failure mode of anything containing feather.
Buy it if you want the hotel feel, and the mite evidence matters more to you than home washing. Skip it if you are allergic to feathers, or you will not plump it daily.
5Panda Memory Foam Bamboo Pillow
Good value memory foam that holds its height, but it is a solid foam block near your face.
Forty four ninety five for a solid block of memory foam in a bamboo viscose cover, with a 30 night trial and a ten year guarantee. Against £149 for the obvious premium alternative, that is the value pick in this category and testers say so.
Two things it does genuinely well. It holds its height, with one tester writing that it maintained that height throughout the night without sinking, which is the main complaint people have about cheap memory foam. And a tester specifically recorded no off-gassing detected, which for a memory foam pillow at this price is unusual and worth saying plainly.
It also carries OEKO-TEX Standard 100 with a published certificate number, which is more than the more expensive Simba publishes. That certificate sets limits on formaldehyde, aryl amines, phthalates, chlorinated phenols and specific flame retardants for the components it covers.
Now the honest framing, because this is the highest exposure item in the ranking on the argument this site cares about. It is a solid block of visco-elastic polyurethane sitting a few centimetres from your face for eight hours a night. Nothing else here is foam in that quantity that close. The tester finding no off-gassing is a real positive, and OEKO-TEX certifies textiles, so its scope on the foam core itself is worth checking rather than assuming. Panda do not publish CertiPUR for this product.
On fire chemistry this is the case where the regulation bites hardest. Polyurethane foam in slab or cushion form has to pass the wood crib test, which is the most demanding filling test in the regulations, and there is no pillow exemption from it. So a UK legal solid polyurethane pillow core is a combustion modified foam, and there is nothing on the pillow to tell you what was used. Panda state compliance with BS 7177, which is the mattress and bed base flammability standard rather than the pillow route, so read that claim carefully.
One more claim worth handling precisely. Panda market the bamboo as naturally antibacterial. Bamboo viscose is regenerated cellulose, chemically the same as any other viscose, and the American regulator has repeatedly acted against sellers making unsubstantiated antibacterial bamboo claims. If a biocide had actually been added, the Biocidal Products Regulation would require the pillow to be labelled with the active substance, and would entitle any buyer to written detail within 45 days free of charge. Asking for that is the practical test of any antibacterial claim on bedding.
The practical complaints: it is far too high for back and front sleepers, the contouring is restrictive if you change position in the night, the foam cannot be washed at all so the core is a permanent reservoir, and the black embroidery shows through white pillowcases.
Buy it if you sleep on your side, you want memory foam, and you are not paying premium prices for it. Skip it if you sleep on your back or front, or foam near your face is the thing you are avoiding.
6Silentnight Deep Sleep Pillow, 2 pack
The only pillow here you can machine wash and tumble dry, but its polyester fill compresses quickly.
Fifteen pounds for two, so £7.50 a pillow, and it earns its place here for one specific reason that has nothing to do with comfort. It is the only pillow in this comparison that fully machine washes and tumble dries.
That matters because of the mite evidence set out further up this page. Washing is the intervention with the best support behind it, and the good pillows mostly cannot take it. A memory foam core is wipe clean only, down needs professional cleaning, latex must never go in a machine. This one goes in at 40, comes out of the tumble dryer, and goes back on the bed. For a child’s bed, an allergy household or a guest room, that is worth more than a lot of the engineering above it.
It is also not bad. Four point two eight out of five from 645 reviews at one retailer, and the useful thing about those reviews is who is writing them. One verified buyer wrote that they have bought dearer pillows that did not give such a comfortable feel. Another said real support for side sleeping, still good after a week. It recovers, it is soft, and it does the job.
What you are giving up is structure and lifespan. It is hollowfibre polyester in a polyester microfibre cover, and hollowfibre compresses. Which? put hollowfibre lifespan at a couple of years and other guidance puts polyester at six months to two years. The retailer classifies it as medium soft and suitable for back sleepers, and it does not have the structure for a broad shouldered side sleeper regardless of what one happy reviewer says.
One review is worth quoting because it names a real failure mode. A buyer wrote that it was a bit too soft and overstuffed, so their head sinks too far into it and they wake with a blocked nose. That is what a pillow that is too soft for you does, and it is a good reminder that cheap does not mean harmless if the loft is wrong for your build.
Two practical warnings. Buyers regularly order a single from one retailer thinking it is the pair, so check what you are buying. And Silentnight describe it as hypoallergenic while the retailer says non allergenic. Both are marketing terms rather than certifications, and Silentnight’s separate anti allergy range is the one that actually carries British Allergy Foundation approval. Do not confuse the two.
Buy it if washability is the point, it is for a child or a guest, or you replace pillows often. Skip it if you have broad shoulders and sleep on your side, or you want it to last.
What the labels don’t tell you
the dust mite allergen on synthetic pillows against feather ones, measured over twelve months
can be machine washed and tumble dried
fire labels on pillows, yet foam cores must pass the toughest filling test
a pillow for the washable Silentnight, against £109 for the Simba
The 30 second check
How we scored these
Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.
4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.
Buy the Woolroom Deluxe for no foam or polyester and home washing, or the Dunlopillo latex for neck pain. For dust mites, wash a cheap Silentnight hot instead.