Home · Kitchen · Dishwashing

The best dishwasher tablets, compared

Six all in one tablets costed per tablet at today's price, and checked for published ingredients, the silver protection chemical, hard water advice, wrapper and hazard label.

By Mrs HouseUpdated October 20266 products compared
Ecover Wrapper Free All in One, 45 tabletsOur pick
3.6
Ecover Wrapper Free All in One, 45 tablets
24p a tablet (45 for £10.80)
✓Full ingredient list published openly
✓Only tablet with no plastic film
✓Uses a gentler silver protector
The 10 second answer

Which one should you buy?

Side by side

Show me tablets that are…

Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.

Ranked by scoreEcover#1 · 3.6smol#2 · 3.5Aldi#3 · 3.3Bio-D#4 · 3.2Finish#5 · 3.0Fairy#6 · 2.7
Full ingredient list published✓✓✕~ranges only✕✕
Water polluting silver protector ruled out✓✓????
No plastic film around the tablet✓✕✕✕✕✕
Says when hard water needs salt✕✕✕✓✓✕
No Danger label for eye damage✓✓??✓✕
Under 20p a tablet✕✕✓✕✓✕
✓ yes✕ no~ partly? not stated
The reviews, ranked

Good, not so good, and the score

Ecover Wrapper Free All in One, 45 tablets1
Best overall

Ecover Wrapper Free All in One, 45 tablets

24p a tablet (45 for £10.80)
3.6

Full ingredient list, no plastic film and a milder hazard label, at a premium price.

Good
✓Full ingredient list published openly
✓Only tablet with no plastic film
✓Uses a gentler silver protector
Not so good
✕Up to 4.4 times the Aldi price
✕No guidance on when to add salt
✕Unwrapped tablets can crumble in the box
See it at Ecover
smol Dishwash, 30 tablets2
Best certified

smol Dishwash, 30 tablets

21.7p a tablet (30 for £6.50)
3.5

A full ingredient list and checkable B Corp status, though its plastic free claim needs care.

Good
✓Full ingredient list on its own page
✓Uses a gentler silver protector
✓Certified B Corp with published score
Not so good
✕Says plastic free, yet tablets have film
✕Subscription only, not in shops
✕No guidance on when to add salt
See it at smol
Aldi Power Force All in One Lemon, 40 tablets3
Best on a budget

Aldi Power Force All in One Lemon, 40 tablets

7.5p a tablet (40 for £2.99)
3.3

By far the cheapest at 7.5p a wash, but Aldi publishes nothing about what is in it.

Good
✓7.5p a tablet, cheapest by far
✓About £80 a year cheaper than dearest
✓Own brands clean well in independent tests
Not so good
✕No ingredient information published at all
✕No hazard warnings shown online
✕Recent rename makes it look discontinued
See it at Aldi
Bio-D Eco Dishwasher Tablets, 30 tablets4
Best for hard water

Bio-D Eco Dishwasher Tablets, 30 tablets

27.2p a tablet (30 for £8.15)
3.2

The only maker honest that hard water still needs salt and rinse aid, made in Yorkshire.

Good
✓Tells you to add salt in hard water
✓Names its tablet film and addresses breakdown
✓200 pack cuts cost to 21.8p
Not so good
✕Ingredient ranges only, no full list
✕No hazard warnings shown online
✕Over three times the Aldi price
See it at Bio-D
Finish Ultimate All in One Lemon, 75 tablets5
Best branded price

Finish Ultimate All in One Lemon, 75 tablets

17.3p a tablet (75 for £13 at Asda)
3.0

The only brand stating when hard water needs salt, but its ingredient list cannot be reached.

Good
✓Publishes its hard water limit
✓Cheapest branded option at 17.3p
✓Milder eye irritation label than Fairy
Not so good
✕No ingredient list reachable anywhere
✕Same box ranges £13 to £19.50
✕2.3 times the cost of Aldi
See it at Asda
Fairy Platinum Plus All in One, 71 tablets6
Avoid

Fairy Platinum Plus All in One, 71 tablets

22.5p a tablet (71 for £15.97)
2.7

The only tablet labelled Danger for serious eye damage, with no readable ingredient list.

Good
✓Well regarded cleaning, loyal users
✓Good on baked on grease
✓Widely stocked and often on multibuy
Not so good
✕Only tablet labelled Danger: serious eye damage
✕Ingredient page returns nothing readable
✕Three times the Aldi price
See it at Asda
What we found

What the labels don’t tell you

2 of 6

publish a full ingredient list, as the law requires.

7.5p to 33.3p

a tablet, for products doing the same job.

50%

price spread on the same Finish box across six retailers on one day.

28.2%

of under fives in film tablet poisoning enquiries had symptoms, against 19.1% for pressed tablets.

Before you buy

The 30 second check

1Work out the price per tablet, because pack sizes and shelf unit prices are deliberately hard to compare.
2Shop around on the same box, as one Finish pack varied by 50 per cent across retailers on one day.
3Check your water hardness by postcode, since in hard water you still need salt and rinse aid.
4Read the hazard label, and keep any tablet marked Danger up high, away from children.
5Use the eco cycle and skip pre rinsing, which uses less water and energy than quick wash.
How we scored these
Works 35%
Made of 25%
Value 15%
Everyday 15%
Honest 10%

Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.

4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.

Final verdict

Ecover Wrapper Free for a full ingredient list and no film, Aldi Power Force at 7.5p if price decides it. Skip Fairy Platinum Plus, the only tablet labelled Danger.

See our pick