The best water filter jugs, compared
Six filter jugs costed by what a cartridge really delivers before its date runs out, and checked for genuine certification, honest claims, waste and owner reviews.
Our pickWhich one should you buy?
Show me jugs that are…
Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.
| Ranked by score | Phox#1 · 3.7 | Brita#2 · 3.5 | Waterdrop#3 · 3.4 | Amazon Basics#4 · 3.2 | Aarke#5 · 3.0 | ZeroWater#6 · 2.2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Keep the cartridge, no plastic pods | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ | ✕ |
| Certification listed in a public register | ✕ | ✕tested, not certified | ✓taste and chlorine only | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ |
| No unsupported PFAS or microplastics claim | ✓ | ✕ | ~sister listings overclaim | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Under 5p a litre to run | ✓ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Jug costs under £20 | ✕ | ✓ | ✕ | ✓ | ✕ | ✓ |
Good, not so good, and the score
1Phox V2 2.2L Glass Water Filter
Keep the cartridge and refill it from a rice paper sachet: low waste, low running cost.
The Phox is the only jug here that solves the actual environmental problem with filter jugs, which is not the jug, it is the thirteen plastic pods a year you throw at it. You keep the cartridge body. Every 45 days or 200 litres you tip in fresh granules from a rice paper sachet. Ocado publishes the full ingredient list for the refill and it reads: cardboard, coconut shell activated carbon, ion exchange beads, eco rice paper bags. That is the whole product. It is made in Scotland, and every part is sold separately, from a £2 grid to a £10 replacement glass jar, so a dropped lid is not a new jug.
On performance it says more than Brita does. The product page states it is certified to European standard EN 17093 for lead, chlorine, nickel, copper, geosmin and 2,4,6-TCP, and that the media meets NSF/ANSI 61 and EN 12915. EN 17093 is a real standard written specifically for jug filters, so naming it is meaningful. What Phox does not publish is a certificate number, a test report number or the name of the lab, and we looked at the product page, the FAQ, the sustainability page and their blog. So the standard is real and the evidence for it is not on the site.
It is also the only brand in this group that makes no PFAS claim and no microplastics claim. In a category where everyone else reaches for those two words, saying nothing is a point in its favour. The recurring complaint is flow rate: several owners report the reservoir draining slowly or clogging, and black carbon carryover in the first few fills.
Buy it if you want the running cost low and the bin empty, and you are willing to take the performance claims on the standard being named rather than on published evidence.
2Brita Marella 2.4L with MAXTRA PRO Pure Performance
The default with a real recycling scheme, but its jug cartridges are tested, not certified.
Brita is the default, and mostly it earns that. It names its filter media in full, four stages including coconut shell microcarbon and ion exchange pearls. It runs a cartridge take back scheme that has existed since 1992 and that we could verify independently, because Lewes and Eastbourne council tells its residents to use it and not to put the cartridges in the kerbside bin. And its own manual is unusually blunt about the hygiene question, telling you filtered water is a perishable food, to drink it within a day, and that people with impaired immunity and babies should still boil it.
The certification is where it comes unstuck. The PFAS claim on the UK product page carries the footnote “tested to JWPAS B.210 and NSF/ANSI 53”. Tested to is not certified to, and the difference is the whole point of a certification body. We searched the NSF register directly. BRITA SE of Taunusstein is listed, but only for plumbed in units: CLARITY, On Line Active, P3000, mypure. The MAXTRA and MAXTRA PRO jug cartridges do not appear anywhere in it. No certificate number, test report number or lab name is published for the jug cartridge on brita.co.uk, its FAQ, or at Robert Dyas or Ocado.
The microplastics claim deserves a look too. Brita says it reduces microparticles at or above 30 micrometres. Most microplastic particles found in drinking water are considerably smaller than 30 micrometres, so the claim is true and much less useful than it sounds. On cost, the honest figure is 5.6p a litre if you buy six cartridges on Amazon and 7.5p if you buy them at Robert Dyas, and thirteen cartridges a year is the highest disposal count in the group.
Buy it if you want the brand with the most owners, a recycling route that actually works, and you are content that the health claims are self tested rather than certified.
3Waterdrop Chubby PT-04W 3.5L
Genuinely certified and cheap to run, but only for chlorine and taste, not health claims.
This is the only jug in the group whose certification we could pull up in the NSF register ourselves and read. Waterdrop’s WD-PF-01A Plus cartridge, made by Qingdao Ecopure, is listed against NSF/ANSI 42 for chlorine reduction and taste and odour reduction, with a 200 gallon service cycle, plus NSF/ANSI 372 for lead free materials. That is a genuine, checkable listing and it puts Waterdrop ahead of Brita on this specific point.
Now read the certificate carefully, because the marketing does not. NSF/ANSI 42 is the aesthetic effects standard. It covers taste, odour and chlorine and it says nothing about health. The Amazon listing for a sister model claims the filter reduces PFOA, PFOS, iron, calcium, copper, mercury and magnesium, and attributes that to an unnamed third party lab with no report number. Those claims sit entirely outside the NSF certification. To Waterdrop’s credit, the listing for this particular model states the position correctly and narrowly, which is why it is the model we picked.
On money it is the cheapest branded option and by a distance. A filter is rated at 757 litres or three months, which works out at 4p a litre and just four cartridges a year against Brita’s thirteen. The catch is that at three litres a day you hit the three month clock at 274 litres, so you are binning a cartridge with almost two thirds of its rated capacity unused. And the UK after sales position looks thin: Trustpilot has the UK site at 2.3 from seven reviews, which is far too small a sample to lean on but points the same way as several Amazon complaints.
Buy it if you want the lowest branded running cost and the fewest cartridge changes, and you are buying it for chlorine and taste rather than for the health claims on the box.
4Amazon Basics 2.3L Water Filter Jug
The cheapest to run for less limescale and better taste, with no health claims made.
£10.12 for the jug and £2.69 a cartridge. That is 3p a litre and £32.77 a year, the cheapest running cost in this comparison, and the cartridges fit Brita jugs too. If your reason for owning a filter jug is that your kettle furs up and your tap water tastes of chlorine, this does that job for a third of what the branded option costs.
It also, without meaning to, behaves better than some of its rivals on claims. There is no lead claim. No PFAS claim. No microplastics claim. It says it reduces chlorine, limescale and other impurities, which is roughly what an activated carbon and ion exchange cartridge does. Nobody is being sold an anxiety here.
What lets it down is that the only piece of assurance offered is the phrase “TUV certified”, with no standard named and no scope given. That could be a materials safety assessment rather than any test of filtration performance, and there is no way to tell from the listing, no certificate number, and no data sheet we could find. It is also the one product here with no independent second source at all, because Amazon is the only place that sells it, so every review you can read comes from one retailer. The complaints are about ergonomics rather than filtration: a jug that tips, a reservoir smaller than a Brita, and a cartridge that some owners needed pliers to remove.
Buy it if you want less limescale and better tasting water at the lowest possible cost, and you are not buying it for anything to do with health.
5Aarke Purifier, 2.36L
A refillable steel cartridge and fully dishwasher safe jug, but expensive to buy and run.
Aarke publishes the most specific performance figures of anyone here, against a named European standard: 80 to 100 per cent chlorine reduction, 80 to 100 per cent copper, 90 to 100 per cent lead and 90 to 100 per cent limescale, each stated as fulfilling EN 17093:2018. The filter is developed with BWT, which is a serious water technology company and which sells the aarke refills in its own shop, so the partnership checks out.
It is also the only jug here that takes the hygiene problem seriously in its design. The cartridge is refillable stainless steel rather than a plastic pod, every part goes in the dishwasher at 60 degrees, and aarke says so explicitly in terms of preventing microbiological growth. Given what the published research says about bacteria in filter jugs, which is in the guide below, that is a real advantage and not just styling.
The problems are money and the company. £99.99 for the jug and 6.7p a litre in granules puts the first year at about £174, roughly five times the Amazon Basics figure. On the testing, aarke says only that materials are tested by independent institutes and names no institute, no report and no certificate number, so the EN 17093 figures are the brand’s own. And while Lakeland shows 4.92 out of 5 from twelve reviews on the jug, aarke.com sits at 3.9 on Trustpilot with 26 per cent one star reviews, which is a very high proportion. The product is liked. Dealing with the company appears not to be.
Buy it if you want a jug you will keep on the counter, you care about being able to put the whole thing through a dishwasher, and the price is genuinely not the constraint.
6Culligan ZeroWater 1.7L, 5 Stage
The only jug certified for lead removal, but £230 or more a year in cartridges.
Start with the thing ZeroWater genuinely has and nobody else here does. Its filters are certified by IAPMO against NSF/ANSI 53, the health effects standard, and NSF/ANSI 42. The published data sheet gives 98.8 to 98.9 per cent lead reduction, 99.8 per cent for PFOA and PFOS, 99.4 to 99.5 per cent for hexavalent chromium. If you live in a property with old lead pipework and you want a jug that has been independently tested for lead, this is the only one in this comparison that qualifies.
Everything after that is difficult. The certified rated capacity in that same data sheet is 15 gallons, which is 56.78 litres. The marketing says 75. Those last eighteen litres are outside the certified envelope, and the filter has no time limit at all, so life is entirely dependent on how mineralised your water is. At three litres a day the cartridge arithmetic lands at 21p to 27.7p a litre, which is £230 to £304 a year. Water UK puts the national average household water and sewerage bill for 2025 to 2026 at £603, so on this usage the cartridges cost between a third and a half of an entire water bill.
And then there are the reviews, which are the worst here by some distance. The new Culligan version of the jug sits at 1.50 out of 5 from four reviews at Lakeland, with not a single review above two stars. The recurring theme across both generations, across Lakeland and Amazon, is a fishy or metallic taste as the filter exhausts, and it exhausts faster than people expect. One long term customer wrote that filters start producing metallic and fishy tasting water after about two weeks, and that the new jug design prevents proper cleaning because the filter attachment layer cannot be removed.
Buy it if you have a specific, identified reason to need certified lead or PFAS reduction from a jug, and you have costed the cartridges properly first.
What the labels don’t tell you
have certification you can find in a public register.
a year in ZeroWater cartridges for two people drinking three litres a day.
is how far limescale removal falls over one cartridge's life, French testing found.
of tap water samples in England and Wales meet the standards, the regulator reports.
The 30 second check
How we scored these
Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.
4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.
Phox V2 for low waste and low running cost, Amazon Basics at £10.12 for cheap limescale control. Skip Culligan ZeroWater unless you need certified lead removal: £230 or more a year in cartridges.