Home · Living room · Home fragrance

The best scented candles, compared

Six home fragrance products, from £12.99 to £63, compared on what each maker discloses, cost per hour, evidence of how they burn and what the science says about burning indoors.

By Mrs HouseUpdated October 20266 products compared
Earl of East Shinrin-Yoku Scented Candle, 170mlOur pick
3.8
Earl of East Shinrin-Yoku Scented Candle, 170ml
£26 for 170ml
✓Names soy wax and where it's grown
✓Wick named: cotton and unbleached linen
✓Points you to the allergen label
The 10 second answer

Which one should you buy?

Side by side

Show me candles that are…

Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.

Ranked by scoreEarl of East#1 · 3.8Price's#2 · 3.3Yankee#3 · 3.2Neom#4 · 3.0White Co#5 · 2.5Diptyque#6 · 2.3
Wax named✓✓✓✕Solvent unnamed~Retailer only✕
Wick material named✓✕~"Natural fibres" only?Diffuser, no wick✕✕
Allergens named on the brand's own page~Points to jar label✕✓✓✕LookFantastic only✕
Nothing burns, so no soot✕✕✕✓✕✕
Under 30p an hour to run✕✓✓✓If left running✕✕
Owner reviews to go on✕✕Two, no text✓✓✓~Brand-level only
✓ yes✕ no~ partly? not stated
The reviews, ranked

Good, not so good, and the score

Earl of East Shinrin-Yoku Scented Candle, 170ml1
Best overall

Earl of East Shinrin-Yoku Scented Candle, 170ml

£26 for 170ml
3.8

The only candle here naming its wax, wick fibre and origin, but nobody has reviewed it.

Good
✓Names soy wax and where it's grown
✓Wick named: cotton and unbleached linen
✓Points you to the allergen label
Not so good
✕No independent reviews of how it burns
✕Certifications given without certificate numbers
✕Only 35 to 40 hours for £26
See it at Earl of East
Price's Candles English Lavender Large Jar, 510g2
Best on a budget

Price's Candles English Lavender Large Jar, 510g

£12.99 for 510g at Tesco
3.3

The cheapest burn here at 13p an hour, bought on arithmetic rather than evidence.

Good
✓13p an hour, the cheapest burn here
✓Up to 100 hours from 510g
✓In supermarkets all year round
Not so good
✕Only two reviews, with no text
✕No allergen statement published online
✕Wick material not published
See it at Tesco
Yankee Candle Vanilla Original Large Jar, 623g3
Most reviews

Yankee Candle Vanilla Original Large Jar, 623g

£23.99 for 623g
3.2

Names its paraffin and six allergens, but owners report soot and tunnelling.

Good
✓Names its wax outright as paraffin
✓Six allergens listed on product page
✓16p to 22p an hour
Not so good
✕Owners report soot and tunnelling
✕Weak scent throw is a repeated complaint
✕Contains Lilial and Lyral, banned in cosmetics
See it at Yankee Candle
Neom Real Luxury Reed Diffuser, 100ml4
Best with no flame

Neom Real Luxury Reed Diffuser, 100ml

£55 for 100ml
3.0

A reed diffuser, so nothing burns, with the best allergen list in the group.

Good
✓Nothing burns, so no soot
✓Best allergen list in the group
✓Refills sold, so the glass is reused
Not so good
✕Carrier liquid, most of the bottle, unnamed
✕£55 for 100ml
✕Discontinued at John Lewis, waitlist elsewhere
See it at Neom
The White Company Seychelles Signature Candle, 140g5
Well liked

The White Company Seychelles Signature Candle, 140g

£25 for 140g
2.5

Owners love the scent, but the brand's own page tells you almost nothing.

Good
✓4.8 out of 5 from 478 reviews
✓Poured and hand-finished in the UK
✓Allergen list available at LookFantastic
Not so good
✕89p an hour, seven times Price's
✕Brand page omits weight, burn time, wax
✕Wick material not published anywhere
See it at The White Company
Diptyque Baies Classic Candle, 190g6
Avoid

Diptyque Baies Classic Candle, 190g

£63 for 190g
2.3

A famous scent, but the weakest disclosure and the highest running cost here.

Good
✓Distinctive fragrance with a long following
✓Clear burn-care instructions from the brand
✓Liberty discloses the wax blend
Not so good
✕£1.26 an hour, the dearest here
✕No wick or allergens named anywhere
✕Owners report tunnelling and uneven burn
See it at Diptyque
What we found

What the labels don’t tell you

1 of 6

products names both its wax and its wick fibre

13p

an hour to burn the Price's jar, against £1.26 for the Diptyque

30 to 70x

more carbon particles from a sooting candle than a steady one

Before you buy

The 30 second check

1Trim the wick and kill the draught, a sooting flame gives off 30 to 70 times more carbon particles.
2Work out the cost per hour, divide the price by the stated burn time before you buy.
3Read "mineral wax" as paraffin, the same Price's jar is sold under both names.
4Do not use price as a guide, the £63 candle names no wax, wick or allergens.
5Soy is not a health upgrade, soy and stearin measured at or above paraffin on particles.
How we scored these
Works 35%
Made of 25%
Value 15%
Everyday 15%
Honest 10%

Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.

4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.

Final verdict

Buy the Earl of East at £26 if you want to know what you are burning, or the Price's jar at £12.99 for the most hours. Skip the £63 Diptyque.

See our pick