Home · Kitchen · Pans and cookware

The best non-stick frying pans, compared

Eight frying pans compared on what the surface is made of, what the brand actually claims, guarantee, oven and utensil limits, and what owners report about the coating lasting.

By Mrs HouseUpdated October 20268 products compared
ProCook Professional Stainless Steel Non-Stick 28cmOur pick
4.0
ProCook Professional Stainless Steel Non-Stick 28cm
£55 for 28cm
✓25 year guarantee on the coating
✓Oven safe to 260C, dishwasher safe
✓4.9 from 193 Trustpilot reviews
The 10 second answer

Which one should you buy?

Side by side

Show me pans that are…

Tap one or more. The ones that don’t qualify fade out, here and in the reviews below.

Ranked by scoreProCook Pro#1 · 4.0De Buyer#2 · 3.9ProCook Tri-Ply#3 · 3.8Ninja#4 · 3.7Tefal#5 · 3.6Dunelm#6 · 2.9GreenPan#7 · 2.9Always Pan#8 · 2.6
No coating at all✕✓✓✕✕✕✕✕
PTFE free✕✓✓✓✕?Coating not named✓✓
Guarantee of 10 years or more✓✕✓✓✕✓Lifetime✕✕
Oven safe to 220C or more✓✕200C, ten minutes✓✓✕?✓✓
Metal utensils allowed✕?✓✓✓?✓✕
Under £50✕✓✕✓✓✓✕✕
✓ yes✕ no~ partly? not stated
The reviews, ranked

Good, not so good, and the score

ProCook Professional Stainless Steel Non-Stick 28cm1
Best overall

ProCook Professional Stainless Steel Non-Stick 28cm

£55 for 28cm
4.0

A normal PTFE non-stick pan, honest about being one, with a 25 year guarantee.

Good
✓25 year guarantee on the coating
✓Oven safe to 260C, dishwasher safe
✓4.9 from 193 Trustpilot reviews
Not so good
✕PTFE, so not fluoropolymer free
✕No metal utensils allowed
✕No certificate behind its PFOA claim
See it at ProCook
De Buyer Mineral B 28cm Carbon Steel2
No coating

De Buyer Mineral B 28cm Carbon Steel

£44 for 28cm
3.9

Carbon steel with nothing to wear off, if you will season it and keep it seasoned.

Good
✓No coating, nothing to flake off
✓Improves with use and outlasts the rest
✓£44, cheaper than five of eight
Not so good
✕Must be seasoned, not non-stick at first
✕Hand wash only, rusts if left wet
✕Oven safe only 200C for ten minutes
See it at De Buyer
ProCook Elite Signature Uncoated Tri-Ply 28cm3
No upkeep

ProCook Elite Signature Uncoated Tri-Ply 28cm

£70 for 28cm, usually £149
3.8

Uncoated stainless with no maintenance, for cooks happy to work without non-stick.

Good
✓Uncoated, with a 25 year guarantee
✓Oven to 260C and dishwasher safe
✓Browns and deglazes better than non-stick
Not so good
✕Not non-stick: eggs and fish stick
✕£149 at full price
✕Only 56 reviews
See it at ProCook
Ninja ZEROSTICK Ceramic Pro 28cm4
Best ceramic

Ninja ZEROSTICK Ceramic Pro 28cm

£32.49 for 28cm, down from £64.99
3.7

The ceramic pan to buy if you want out of PTFE, with a real guarantee.

Good
✓10 year guarantee at £32.49
✓Oven safe to 285C, the highest here
✓Metal utensil safe, unusual for ceramic
Not so good
✕Ceramic releases food worse than PTFE
✕3.8 on Ninja's own site, lowest here
✕Owners report peeling and blistering coatings
See it at Ninja
Tefal Expertise Plus Induction 28cm5
Household name

Tefal Expertise Plus Induction 28cm

£36 for 28cm
3.6

A familiar PTFE pan from a brand open about its coating, but it cannot go in the oven.

Good
✓Openly explains what PTFE is
✓Metal utensil safe
✓Thermo-Spot shows when it is hot
Not so good
✕Not oven safe at all
✕Only a two year guarantee
✕No maximum temperature published
See it at Tefal
Dunelm Scoville Neverstick 28cm6
Cheapest here

Dunelm Scoville Neverstick 28cm

£18 for 28cm
2.9

Unbeatable on price with a lifetime guarantee, but it will not say what the coating is.

Good
✓£18, the cheapest here
✓Lifetime guarantee, longest on the page
✓4.7 from 432 reviews
Not so good
✕Does not say what the coating is
✕No oven, heat or utensil guidance
✕No review text to check durability
See it at Dunelm
GreenPan Premiere Ceramic Non-Stick 28cm7
Overpriced ceramic

GreenPan Premiere Ceramic Non-Stick 28cm

£99.90 for 28cm
2.9

The dearest pan here with a two year guarantee and an asterisked PFAS free claim.

Good
✓Genuinely PTFE free ceramic coating
✓Oven to 220C, metal utensil safe
✓Dishwasher safe
Not so good
✕£99.90 with only a two year guarantee
✕PFAS free claim carries an asterisk
✕Owners report release going within a year
See it at GreenPan
Our Place Ceramic Non-Stick Always Pan, 26cm8
Avoid

Our Place Ceramic Non-Stick Always Pan, 26cm

£89 for 26cm
2.6

The best looking pan here, with the strictest care rules and owners reporting chipping.

Good
✓Best looking pan on the page
✓Broadest chemical claim of the eight
✓Three year warranty, longer than GreenPan's
Not so good
✕£89 for a smaller 26cm pan
✕Hand wash only, no metal utensils
✕Owners report chipping from two weeks in
See it at Our Place
What we found

What the labels don’t tell you

0 of 8

brands publish a certificate or test report behind their chemical claims

7 to 14x

more force needed to release food from ceramic than from PTFE in independent testing

2020

the year PFOA was banned in Europe, so every pan here is PFOA free

25 years

guarantee on the £55 ProCook, against two years on the £99.90 GreenPan

Before you buy

The 30 second check

1Learn the three words, PFOA free means nothing, PTFE free is a real claim.
2Buy the guarantee, not the slogan, here they run from two years to 25.
3Check the utensil rule, metal is fine on some pans and forbidden on others.
4Check the oven limit, from 200C for ten minutes to 285C, and one not at all.
5Never heat a coated pan empty, and keep it off open flame.
How we scored these
Works 35%
Made of 25%
Value 15%
Everyday 15%
Honest 10%

Every product on Mrs House gets the same five scores, with the same weights. We read each ingredient or materials list, chase the safety data and certificates, and look for a published test behind every claim on the box.

4.5 and up: approved. 4.0 to 4.4: recommended. 3.0 to 3.9: fine, with reservations. Under 3.0: not recommended.

Final verdict

Buy the ProCook Professional at £55 for non-stick with a 25 year guarantee, or the De Buyer at £44 for no coating at all. Skip the £89 Our Place Always Pan.

See our pick